E&R 2007-07-25
~
NEW HANOVER COUNTY BOARD OF
EQUALIZATION AND REVIEW, JULY 25, 2007
I
BOOK 1
PAGE 376
ASSEMBLY
The New Hanover County Board of Equalization and Review met on Wednesday, July 25,2007, at
9:00 a.m. in Conference Room 601 ofthe New Hanover County Government Center, 230 Government Center
Drive, Wilmington, North Carolina. The purpose of the meeting was to hear appeals filed by property owners
regarding their tax value assessments.
Members present were: Chairman William A. Caster, Vice-Chairman Robert G. Greer, Commissioner
William A. Kopp, Jr., and Commissioner Nancy H. Pritchett.
Commissioner Ted Davis, Jr. was absent.
Staff members present were: Tax Administrator Robert C. Glasgow, Appraisal Supervisor Henry 1.
Montgomery, Deputy County Attorney Kemp Burpeau, and Deputy Clerk to the Board Teresa P. Elmore.
Chairman Caster called the meeting to order and informed appellants that the Board would hear the
appeals and make decisions following the hearings. The Tax Administrator will notify each appellant by mail
of the Board's decision.
Tax Administrator Glasgow reported that the appeals scheduled to be heard on this date were in the
Porters Neck area and that Roger Kelley, the Tax Appraiser who had prepared the cases had a death in the
family and would not be in attendance. Appraisal Supervisor Montgomery had reviewed the cases and he
made additional adjustments.
I
After hearing the first case where a further reduction in the assessed value was recommended, and the
taxpayer was unaware of the change, the Board recessed the meeting to allow staff to meet with the appellants
to give them their revised values. This was done to allow the taxpayers who were in agreement with the new
assessed value to leave without having to wait to give their appeal.
TAX APPEAL PRESENTATIONS
The Board heard appeal presentations from the following individuals regarding the 2007 tax
assessment of real property:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
I 8.
9.
Sam Noel, property owner of 8614 Hammock Dunes Drive, Wilmington, NC; Parcel ID; R03708-
003-007-000
Bruce C. Baliko, property owner of 8612 Hammock Dunes Drive, Wilmington, NC; Parcel ID
R03708-003-008-000
Maryann Maitland, property owner of 8610 Hammock Dunes Drive, Wilmington, NC; Parcel ill
R03708-003-009-000
Valerie A. Desanti, property owner of 8602 Hammock Dunes Drive, Wilmington, NC; Parcel ID
R03708-003-0I3-000
Clarence E. Hjelte Jr, property owner 8605 Hammock Dunes Drive, Wilmington, NC; Parcel ill
R03708-003-0 19-000
Joseph R. CapeIIini, property owner of 843 7 Fazio Drive, Wilmington, NC; Parcel ill R03708-005-
004-000
Joseph D. Griggs, property owner of 8321 Vintage Club Cir, Wilmington, NC; Parcel ill R03708-
007 -001 -000
Lorraine Alipanah, property owner of 8504 Hammock Dunes Drive, Wilmington, NC; Parcel ill
R03 708-008-0 1 0-000
David J. Riggs, property owner of 1508 Jupiter Hills Circle, Wilmington, NC; Parcel ill R03712-004-
010-000
8cv
~
NEW HANOVER COUNTY BOARD OF
EQUALIZATION AND REVIEW, JULY 25, 2007
BOOK 1
PAGE 377
..........',.,
10. Joseph S. Treman, property owner of8347 Vintage Club Cir, Wilmington, NC; Parcel ID R03712-
005-005-000
BREAK: Chairman Caster called a lunch break from 12: 1 0 p.m. until 1 :00 p.m.
11. Harry Timothy Bass, property owner of 8500 Hammock Dunes Drive, Wilmington, NC; Parcel ID
R03 708-008-0 12-000
12. Bruce P. and Patricia Myers, property owners of 1019 Wild Dunes Cir, Wilmington, NC; Parcel ID
R02919-009-0 1 0-000
13. Bob Skrzycki, property owner of 1013 Wild Dunes Cir, Wilmington, NC; Parcel ID R02919-009-
013-000
14. David A. Bauereis, property owner of 416 Black Diamond Drive, Wilmington, NC; Parcel ID
R03700-002-038-000
15. Gary R. and Virginia A. Teachey, property owners of 8713 Champion Hills Drive, Wilmington, NC;
ParcelID R03700-002-060-000
16. Lisa R. McLean, property owner of 8706 Champion Hills Dr, Wilmington, NC; Parcel ID R03700-
002-062-000
17. Frederick E. Meiser, property owner of 1806 Hartefield National, Wilmington, NC; Parcel ID
R03 700-002-074-000
18. Beverly C. Butler, property owner of 411 White Columns Way, Wilmington, NC; Parcel ID R03700-
002-080-000
19. Lev A. and Milla L. Klebanov, propertyownersof423 White Columns Way, Wilmington, NC; Parcel
IDR03700-002-086-000
20. Michael A. and Julienne B. Orr, property owners of 8335 Vintage Club Circle, Wilmington, NC;
Parcel ID R03712-005-011-000
21. Cornelius Cahill, property owner of 8716 Champion Hills Drive, Wilmington, NC; Parcel ID
R03700-002-130-000
22. Joseph M. Damitz, property owner of8822 Champion Hills Dr, Wilmington, NC; Parcel ill R03700-
002- 139-000
23. Stephen 1. Lucas, property owner of 8327 Vintage Club Circle, Wilmington, NC; Parcel ID
R03712-005-015-000
In deliberations after the hearing of the appeals, the Board affirmed the assessed values as follows:
Parcel ID
R03 708-003-007 -000
R03708-003-008-000
R03708-003-009-000
R03 708-003-0 1 0-000
R03 708-003-011-000
R03 708-003-0 12-000
R03 708-003-013-000
LGV
Owner
Assessed
Value
Noel Family Trust $320,000
8614 Hammock Dunes Drive, Wilmington, NC
Baliko Bruce C Teresa M $348,228
8612 Hammock Dunes Drive, Wilmington, NC
Maitland E F Maryann Liv Trust $355,241
8610 Hammock Dunes Drive, Wilmington, NC
Mitchell John L Rachel T $324,329
8608 Hammock Dunes Drive, Wilmington, NC
Fulton Douglas J Sharyn L $360,374
8606 Hammock Dunes Drive, Wilmington, NC
Reis Doreen P Revocable Trust $358,076
8604 Hammock Dunes Drive, Wilmington, NC
Desanti Valerie A $329,627
8602 Hammock Dunes Drive, Wilmington, NC
Affirmed
Value
$320,000 - less 20% land
adjustment
$348,228 - less 20% land
adjustment
$320,000- less 20% land
adjustment
$324,329 -less 20% land
adjustment
$360,374 -less 20% land
adjustment
$358,076 -less 20% land
adjustment
$315,000 - less 20% land
adjustment
~
NEW HANOVER COUNTY BOARD OF BOOK 1
I EQUALIZATION AND REVIEW, JULY 25, 2007 PAGE 378
Assessed Affirmed
Parcel ID Owner Value Value
R03 708-003-016-000 Holt William W Etal $328,000 $328,000 -less 20% land
8611 Hammock Dunes Drive, Wilmington, NC adjustment
R03 708-003-017 -000 Reider Brett D Sara L $284,000 $284,000 - less 20% land
8609 Hammock Dunes Drive, Wilmington, NC adjustment
R03 708-003-0 19-000 Hjelte Clarence E Jr Dianne J $328,000 $328,000 - less 20% land
8605 Hammock Dunes Drive, Wilmington, NC adjustment
R03708-003-020-000 Swain M A $289,000 $289,000 -less 20% land
8603 Hammock Dunes Drive, Wilmington, NC adjustment
R03708-005-003-000 Evans Gerald S Peggy J $721,926 $721,926
8433 Fazio Drive, Wilmington, NC
R03708-005-004-000 Capellini Joseph R Sherry A $534,000 $534,000
8437 Fazio Drive, Wilmington, NC
R03 708-007 -001-000 Griggs Joseph D Etal $452,959 $435,000
8321 Vintage Club Circle, Wilmington, NC
R03 708-007 -007 -000 Lowry Richard C Judith K $545,923 $545,923
8309 Vintage Club Circle, Wilmington, NC
R03 708-007-010-000 Pfisterer Jack N Joan E $372,000 $372,000
8303 Vintage Club Circle, Wilmington, NC
R03708-008-003-000 Vescovi Peter J Linda R $312,630 $312,630 - less 20% land
8505 Hammock Dunes Drive, Wilmington, NC adjustment
R03708-008-009-000 Jenkins David B Suzanne R $377,748 $377,748 -less 20% land
I 8506 Hammock Dunes Drive, Wilmington, NC adjustment
R03 708-008-0 1 0-000 Alipanah Manouchehr Lorraine $363,229 $325,000 - less 20% land
8504 Hammock Dunes Drive, Wilmington, NC adjustment
R03 708-008-0 12-000 Bass Harry Timothy $355,311 $330,000 - less 20% land
8500 Hammock Dunes Drive, Wilmington, NC adjustment
R03712-003-006-000 Mintzell William Revoc Liv Tr $542,000 $542,000
1604 Jupiter Hills Circle, Wilmington, NC
R03 712-003-010-000 Pollock Robert S Rosemary B $256,000 $256,000
8408 Fazio Drive, Wilmington, NC
R03 712-003-0 12-000 Akerhielm David A Etal $517,000 $517,000
8416 Fazio Drive, Wilmington, NC
R03712-004-005-000 Banks Steven P Brenda P $654,000 $654,000
1528 Jupiter Hills Circle, Wilmington, NC
R03 712-004-0 1 0-000 Riggs David J Penelope L $508,557 $508,557 - adjustment
1508 Jupiter Hills Circle, Wilmington, NC for a flood zone area
R03 712-004-0 13-000 Schoolfield John H Susan R $612,047 $612,047 - adjustment
1513 Jupiter Hills Circle, Wilmington, NC for a flood zone area
R03 712-004-018-000 Stewart J T III Ann W $593,000 $593,000
8417 Fazio Drive, Wilmington, NC
R03712-004-020-000 Oxendine Earl B Vanessa C $610,520 $610,520
8425 Fazio Drive, Wilmington, NC
R03712-005-005-000 Treman Joseph S Barbara M $453,723 $425,000
8347 Vintage Club Circle, Wilmington, NC
R03 712-005-010-000 Pope William 0 Mary Jo $460,729 $460,729
8337 Vintage Club Circle, Wilmington, NC
R04516-00 1-00 1-000 Johnson James Evans Jr $1,572,253 $1,572,253
75 S Beach Road, Wilmington, NC
I R04520-002-001-000 Johnson James Evans Jr $1,289,000 $1,289,000
74 S Beach Road, Wilmington, NC
R05208-002-00 1-000 1 JIB LLC $2,781,505 $2,781,505
1 JIB Road, Wilmington, NC
OSP
.....4
NEW HANOVER COUNTY BOARD OF
EQUALIZATION AND REVIEW, JULY 25, 2007
Parcel ID
R02919-009-0 1 0-000
R02919-009-013-000
R02919-009-0 15-000
R02919-009-026-000
R02919-009-031-000
R02919-0 1 0-005-000
R03700-002-020-000
R03700-002-029-000
R03 700-002-03 8-000
R03700-002-039-000
R03700-002-059-000
R03700-002-060-000
R03700-002-062-000
R03700-002-066-000
R03700-002-068-000
R03700-002-073-000
R03700-002-074-000
R03700-002-079-000
R03700-002-080-000
R03700-002-086-000
R03700-002-088-000
R03700-002-092-000
R03700-002-098-000
R03700-002-130-000
R03700-002-139-000
R03700-002-162-000
hjh
,...; C-" V
Owner
Assessed
Value
Myers Bruce P Patricia $366,866
1019 Wild Dunes Circle, Wilmington, NC
Skrzycki Family Trust The $356,534
1013 Wild Dunes Circle, Wilmington, NC
Schauf Alice T $367,704
1009 Wild Dunes Circle, Wilmington, NC
McDonough Sean Janet A $364,000
925 Wild Dunes Circle, Wilmington, NC
Murray Jay A Michelle R $526,599
909 Wild Dunes Circle, Wilmington, NC
Tallent William S Karen L $375,220
1030 Wild Dunes Circle, Wilmington, NC
Stair John E Jr Suzanne M $445,000
403 Black Diamond Drive, Wilmington, NC
Bryden David W Pamela B $152,232
421 Black Diamond Drive, Wilmington, NC
Bauereis David A Elizabeth I $435,810
416 Black Diamond Drive, Wilmington, NC
Warfield Delores J $154,000
414 Black Diamond Drive, Wilmington, NC
Recht G Thomas Katharine J $596,991
8802 Old Overton Way, Wilmington, NC
Teachey Gary R Virginia A $714,000
8713 Champion Hills Drive, Wilmington, NC
McLean Gregory S Lisa R $624,148
8706 Champion Hills Drive, Wilmington, NC
Everette Jack L N Donna Jo S $435,000
1807 Karsten Creek Way, Wilmington, NC
Fontana Gary W Jeanne M $616,718
1804 Karsten Creek Way, Wilmington, NC
Perez Rosemarie Andress $437,000
1805 Hartefield National Lane, Wilmington, NC
Meiser Frederick E Dorothy A $505,980
1806 Hartefield National Lane, Wilmington, NC
Ramsey Jane S Rev Trust $531,000
409 White Columns Way, Wilmington, NC
Butler Beverly C Thomas M $539,000
411 White Columns Way, Wilmington, NC
Klebanov Lev A Milla L $586,000
423 White Columns Way, Wilmington, NC
Baer John H Julia M $533,000
438 White Columns Way, Wilmington, NC
Nickol Jean A $539,000
430 White Columns Way, Wilmington, NC
Bebb Raymond Janet $475,000
418 White Columns Way, Wilmington, NC
Cahill Cornelius $608, 570
8716 Champion Hills Drive, Wilmington, NC
Damitz Joseph M Corinne C $594,820
8822 Champion Hills Drive, Wilmington, NC
Caglarcan Louise C Eral $840,615
8937 Champion Hills Drive, Wilmington, NC
BOOK 1
PAGE 379
Affirmed
Value
$366,866
$356,534
$367,704
$364,000
$526,599
$375,220
$445,000
$152,232
$420,000/$373,000
$154,000
$596,991
$714,000
$624,148
$435,000
$616,718
$437,000
$505,980
$531,000
$510,367 -20% reduction
for odd shape lot
$546,000
$533,000
$539,000
$475,000
$580,000 -less reduction
for vaulted ceiling area
$560,000 -less $10 sq ft
for lot adjustment
$840,615
~
NEW HANOVER COUNTY BOARD OF BOOK 1
I EQUALIZATION AND REVIEW, JULY 25, 2007 PAGE 380
Assessed Affirmed
Parcel ill Owner Value Value
R03 700-002-204-000 Adair Family Trust $553,500 $553,500
8721 Lowes Island Drive, Wilmington, NC
R03 712-005-011-000 Orr Michael A Julienne B $432,418 $410,000 $404, 994-
8335 Vintage Club Circle, Wilmington, NC reduction for land value
R03 712-005-015-000 Lucas Stephen J J Marie $429,000 $408,000
8327 Vintage Club Circle, Wilmington, NC
R03712-005-017-000 Elmer Ann B $533,000 $533,000
8323 Vintage Club Circle, Wilmington, NC
R03716-002-003-000 Barwick Hugh B Jr $1,340,461 $1,340,461
8300 Bald Eagle Lane, Wilmington, NC
R03 716-003-015-000 Wedgeworth Donald Phyllis $425,000 $425,000
8113 Bald Eagle Lane, Wilmington, NC
TAX APPEALS WITHDRAWN
Tax Administrator Glasgow reported that the following appellants have agreed to an adjusted
value and withdrawn their appeals. The Board affirmed the assessed values of the following:
Assessed Affirmed
Parcel ill Owner Value Value
RO 1900-002-008-004 Dowless Joseph Margie E $20,074 $20,074
I 4002 Ennis Acres Drive, Wilmington, NC
RO 1900-002-0 16-000 Dowless Margie E $360 $360
4006 Ennis Acres Drive, Wilmington, NC
R02920-003-0 14-000 Zamparelle Frederick L Laurie $379,330 $379,330
8902 Mahogany Run, Wilmington, NC
R02920-003-020-000 DiMartino Michael Rose B $1,005,003 $1,005,003
8905 Saint Ives Place, Wilmington, NC
R02920-003-022-000 Munoz C Frank Lourdes T Etal $1,005,292 $1,005,292
8901 Saint Ives Place, Wilmington, NC
R03017-001-001-000 Jefferies John R $784,579 $784,579
1701 Futch Creek Road, Wilmington, NC
R03611-006-004-000 Hajzak Peter Rosemary $19,000 $19,000
138 Beawood Road, Wilmington, NC
R03611-006-005-000 Hajzak Peter Rosemary $149,664 $149,664
142 Beawood Road, Wilmington, NC
R03 707-001-001-000 Costello Timothy D Kimberly A $884,621 $884,621
8703 Thomblade Circle, Wilmington, NC
R03712-001-017-000 Dunn Nancy W $1,120,857 $1,120,857
8312 Bald Eagle Lane, Wilmington, NC
R03712-002-008-000 Beagle Wayne Kimberly $250,000 $250,000
8337 Bald Eagle Lane, Wilmington, NC
R03 712-002-013-000 Beagle Wayne Etal $180,000 $180,000
8409 Bald Eagle Lane, Wilmington, NC
R03 712-002-0 18-000 Brinson Jacob $415,797 $415,797
8429 Bald Eagle Lane, Wilmington, NC
R03 712-002-019-000 Blalock Charles M $408,636 $408,636
I 8433 Bald Eagle Lane, Wilmington, NC
R03 720-00 1-006-000 Foster Robert D Jr Karen K $1,265,343 $1,265,343
8024 Bald Eagle Lane, Wilmington, NC
R04207-009-009-003 Mitchell Jewell M $32,860 $32,860
1525 Mame Drive, Wilmington, NC
GSV
~
NEW HANOVER COUNTY BOARD OF BOOK 1
EQUALIZATION AND REVIEW, JULY 25, 2007 PAGE 381 ........'
Assessed Affirmed
Parcel ID Owner Value Value
R04814-0 12-009-000 Monroe Dorothy Mae $65,032 $65,032
1003 Rankin Street, Wilmington, NC
R04816-0 17 -002-000 Weisman Richard A $257,900 $257,900
114 Barnard Drive, Wilmington, NC
R0551 0-009-0 15-000 Wynne Frances H $173,844 $173,844
4114 Hoggard Drive, Wilmington, NC
R06600-003-0 1 0-000 Smith Letha Mae Life Estate $129,766 $129,766
525 Ponderosa Lane, Wilmington, NC
R076 1 6-003-002-00 1 Russ Denver C $125,373 $125,373
5503 Myrtle Grove Road, Wilmington, NC
R09217-023-013-000 Smith H Winfield Jr $407,062 $407,062
434 S Fourth Avenue, Wilmington, NC
MEETING SCHEDULE
The Board added another meeting to its schedule for August 24,2007, at 9:00 a.m. until 5:00 p.m.
ADJOURNMENT
There being no further business, Chairman Caster recessed the 2007 Board of Equalization and
Review at 4:45 p.m. The meeting will reconvene on August 14,2007 at 9:00 a.m.
Respectfully submitted,
~~~
Teresa P. Elmore
Deputy Clerk to the Board
lEV