E&R 2007-08-14
I
I
I
~
NEW HANOVER COUNTY BOARD OF
EQUALIZATION AND REVIEW, AUGUST 14,2007
ASSEMBLY
The New Hanover County Board of Equalization and Review met on Tuesday, August 14,2007, at
9:00 a.m. in Conference Room 601 ofthe New Hanover County Government Center, 230 Government Center
Drive, Wilmington, North Carolina. The purpose ofthe meeting was to hear appeals filed by property owners
regarding their tax value assessments.
BOOK 1
PAGE 382
Members present were: Chairman William A. Caster, Vice-Chairman Robert G. Greer, Commissioner
William A. Kopp, Jr., and Commissioner Nancy H. Pritchett.
Chairman Caster arrived after the morning session. Commissioner Pritchett left before the afternoon
session. Commissioner Ted Davis, Jr. was absent for both sessions.
Staff members present were: Tax Administrator Robert C. Glasgow, Appraisal Supervisor Henry 1.
Montgomery, Revaluation Coordinator Roger Kelley, Assistant County Attorney Sharon Huffman, and
Deputy Clerk to the Board Teresa P. Elmore.
Vice-Chairman Greer called the meeting to order and informed the appellants that the Board would
hear the appeals and make decisions following the hearings. The Tax Administrator will notify each appellant
by mail ofthe Board's decision.
Tax Administrator Glasgow reported that the appeals scheduled to be heard on this date were in the
Porter's Neck area and that Roger Kelley, the Tax Appraiser for the area, was in attendance to answer any
questions.
TAX APPEAL PRESENTATIONS
The Board heard appeal presentations from the following individuals regarding the 2007 tax
assessment of real property:
1. Edith T. Sullivan, property owner of31 0 South Fourth Street, Wilmington, NC; Parcel ill R05405-
020-013-000
2. Richard L. Harrison and property owner Bettie H. Harrison of 1216 Congressional Lane, Wilmington,
NC; Parcel ID R0291 9-003-01 6-000
3. Roger F. Wells, property owner of 1205 Congressional Lane, Wilmington, NC; Parcel ID R02919-
003-024-000
4. Jeffrey S. Gunz, property owner of8705 Lincolnshire Lane, Wilmington, NC; Parcel ill R03706-002-
007 -000
5. Robert Ronne, property owner of 8700 Lincolnshire Lane, Wilmington, NC; Parcel ill R03706-002-
009-000
6. Michael J. Cahill, property owner of 8702 Interlachen Circle, Wilmington, NC; Parcel ill R03706-
002-018-000
7. Edna M. Goerges, property owner of633 Wild Dunes Circle, Wilmington, NC; Parcel ID R03707-
006-014-000
8. Ruth A. Betz, property owner of 635 Wild Dunes Circle, Wilmington, NC; Parcel ID R03 707 -006-
015-000
9. Robert J. and Barbara 1. Kastl, property owners of 639 Wild Dunes Circle, Wilmington, NC; Parcel
ID R03707-006-017-000
BREAK: Vice-Chairman Greer called a lunch break from 12:10 p.m. until 1:00 p.m.
Chairman Caster reconvened the meeting.
17817
. .....4
NEW HANOVER COUNTY BOARD OF
EQUALIZATION AND REVIEW, AUGUST 14,2007
BOOK 1
PAGE 383
.....,.",.,
10. Richard C. and Bernice H. Walsh, property owners of 1 11 1 Congressional Lane, Wilmington, NC;
Parcel ID R02919-003-037-000
11. Harold M. and Ann M. Garrett, property owners of 108 Hallbrook Farms Circle, Wilmington, NC;
Parcel ID R03707-003-020-000
12. Robert E. Kendig and property owner Jeanne F. Kendig of 641 Wild Dunes Circle, Wilmington, NC;
Parcel ID R03707-006-018-000
13. Melissa Bass, property owner of 1009 Butler National Lane, Wilmington, NC; Parcel ill R03707-
006-022-000
14. Waldimero and Regina CoscarelIi, property owners of 8600 Fazio Drive, Wilmington, NC; Parcel ill
R03 708-006-001-000
In deliberations after the hearing of the appeals, the Board affirmed the assessed values as follows:
Assessed Affirmed
Parcel ID Owner Value Value
R05405-020-0 13-000 Sullivan Edith T $171,858 $171,858
310 S 4th Street, Wilmington, NC
R02919-003-002-000 Wilson Temple B James W $530,356 $508,737
1100 Tennwood Drive, Wilmington, NC
R02919-003-012-000 Hunter John D Kristin Z $167,136 $167,136
1208 Congressional Lane, Wilmington, NC
R02919-003-0 13-000 Robertson Darrell C Phyllis C $481,659 $444,159
1210 Congressional Lane, Wilmington, NC
R02919-003-0 16-000 Harrison Bettie H $555,579 $540,000 - adjustment for
1216 Congressional Lane, Wilmington, NC easements in land value
R02919-003-021-000 Tillett Nancy R $519,023 $469,039
1213 Congressional Lane, Wilmington, NC
R02919-003-024-000 Wells Judith C Roger F $451,990 $451,990
1205 Congressional Lane, Wilmington, NC
R02919-003-029-000 Breen John J Vivian A $462,144 $462,144
8708 Bardmoor Circle, Wilmington, NC
R02919-0 10-027 -000 Murphy James L Linda J $568,541 $568,541
916 Wild Dunes Circle, Wilmington, NC
R03706-002-002-000 Lapufsky Ira L Joyce M $605,807 $605,807
813 Wild Dunes Circle, Wilmington, NC
R03706-002-006-000 Burch Mary B Steven R $517,372 $517,372
8709 Lincolnshire Lane, Wilmington, NC
R03 706-002-007 -000 Gunz Jeffrey S $485,383 $485,383
8705 Lincolnshire Lane, Wilmington, NC
R03706-002-009-000 Ronne Robert Elizabeth $610,852 $586,949 - adjustment for
8700 Lincolnshire Lane, Wilmington, NC special needs accessibility
R03706-002-011-000 Kindt James K $493,237 $493,237
8708 Lincolnshire Lane, Wilmington, NC
R03 706-002-0 16-000 Frazier Jonnie Lynn $617,088 $590,892
8701 Interlachen Circle, Wilmington, NC
R03 706-002-018-000 Cahill Margaret G Michael J $632,546 $584,712 - adjustment for
8702 Interlachen Circle, Wilmington, NC square footage of house
R03707-004-011-000 O'Grady Jacqueline $616,924 $562,360
708 Wild Dunes Circle, Wilmington, NC
R03 707-005-001-000 Robinson Carl F Jacqueline M $585,393 $561,655
8704 Interlachen Circle, Wilmington, NC
R03707-005-006-000 Stine Larry W Judith A $637,361 $596,000
1004 Butler National Lane, Wilmington, NC
C' (\ '
(J t, t7
~
NEW HANOVER COUNTY BOARD OF BOOK 1
I EQUALIZATION AND REVIEW, AUGUST 14,2007 PAGE 384
Assessed Affirmed
Parcel ID Owner Value Value
R03 707 -006-014-000 Goerges Edna M Revocable Trust $388,108 $388,108
633 Wild Dunes Circle, Wilmington, NC
R03 707-006-015-000 Betz William J Ruth A $384,647 $384,647
635 Wild Dunes Circle, Wilmington, NC
R03707-006-017-000 Kastl Robert J Barbara J $391,124 $385,000 - adjustment for
639 Wild Dunes Circle, Wilmington, NC damage to house
R02919-003-035-000 Carney Rebecca $409,941 $380,000
1115 Congressional Lane, Wilmington, NC
R02919-003-036-000 Garfinkel Michael N Andrea G $457,582 $427,779
1113 Congressional Lane, Wilmington, NC
R02919-003-03 7 -000 Walsh Richard C Bernice H $467,587 $467,587
1111 Congressional Lane, Wilmington, NC
R02919-005-004-000 Culp H Lawrence Wendy $726,929 $672,259
124 Hallbrook Farms Circle, Wilmington, NC
R02919-006-006-000 Phillips Jimmie Ray Mary L $677,480 $677,480
117 Hallbrook Farms Circle, Wilmington, NC
R02919-007 -001-000 Howell Burl C Ann M $429,210 $420,060
1100 Congressional Lane, Wilmington, NC
R02919-007 -004-000 Norman Richard FEtal $465,273 $468,935
1106 Congressional Lane, Wilmington, NC
R02920-003-003-000 Malone James P Diane $204,536 $163,629
I 8705 Lake Nona Lane, Wilmington, NC
R02920-003-005-000 Dragity Milan G Susan H $637,766 $533,000
8712 Lake Nona Lane, Wilmington, NC
R02920-003-0 1 0-000 Binder Michael N Gisela A $782,342 $658,893
8632 Vintage Club Drive, Wilmington, NC
R03 707-003-005-000 Lerose George V Theresa Anne S $602,443 $535,881
1009 Callawasse Island Dr, Wilmington, NC
R03 707 -003-012-000 Sowers William R Jr Mary J $679,694 $679,694
8721 Fazio Drive, Wilmington, NC
R03 707-003-014-000 Pennino Del A $602,228 $591,926
8713 Fazio Drive, Wilmington, NC
R03 707-003-016-000 Huie Robert K Katherine S $585,746 $585,746
8705 Fazio Drive, Wilmington, NC
R03707-003-019-000 Pollard Family Trust $1,127,353 $1,000,438
101 Hallbrook Farms Circle, Wilmington, NC
R03 707-003-020-000 Garrett Harold M Ann M $726,456 $691,710 - adjustment for
108 Hallbrook Farms Circle, Wilmington, NC 1 ~ story from 1 % house
R03 707 -006-018-000 Kendig Jeanne F $417,582 $417,582
641 Wild Dunes Circle, Wilmington, NC
R03 707 -006-020-000 Prestileo Joseph L Doris L $611,890$ 611 ,890
1013 Butler National Lane, Wilmington, NC
R03 707-006-022-000 Bass Melissa $568,208 $547,045 - adjustment for
1009 Butler National Lane, Wilmington, NC condition of house to B-
R03 707-006-023-000 Yuchmow Eleanore $179,721 $179,721
1007 Butler National Lane, Wilmington, NC
R03708-002-005-000 Hitchcock R Cyrus Janice W $532,319 $471,538
8656 Vintage Club Drive, Wilmington, NC
I R03708-002-008-000 Evers Jerry J Elizabeth T $542,320 $542,320
8644 Vintage Club Drive, Wilmington, NC
R03708-003-006-000 Adams David A Jacquelyn $437,562 $312,544
8608 Vintage Club Drive, Wilmington, NC
98~ ~
NEW HANOVER COUNTY BOARD OF
EQUALIZATION AND REVIEW, AUGUST 14,2007
BOOK 1
PAGE 385
Parcel ID
Owner
Assessed
Value
Affirmed
Value
R03708-006-005-000
Coscarelli Waldimero Regina
8600 Fazio Drive, Wilmington, NC
Upchurch Mary G
8616 Fazio Drive, Wilmington, NC
$761,852
$214,704
$711,848 - adjustment for
non-golf course lot
$214,704
R03 708-006-001-000
TAX APPEALS WITHDRAWN
Tax Administrator Glasgow reported that the following appellants have agreed to an adjusted value
and withdrawn their appeals. The board affirmed the assessed values of the following:
Assessed Affirmed
Parcel- In Owner Value Value
RO 1900-002-008-004 Dowless Joseph Margie E $20,074 $20,074
4002 Ennis Acres Drive, Wilmington, NC
RO 1900-002-0 16-000 Dowless Margie E $360 $360
4006 Ennis Acres Drive, Wilmington, NC
R02919-003-0 18-000 Bishop Marilyn M $442,502 $442,502
1218 Congressional Lane, Wilmington, NC
R02919-003-023-000 Hemiksen John A Agatha N $486,637 $486,637
1209 Congressional Lane, Wilmington, NC
R02919-003-027 -000 Miller Raymond C Dolores M $382,905 $382,905
8704 Bardmoor Circle, Wilmington, NC
R02919-003-028-000 Wilson Trust $450,668 $450,668
8706 Bardmore, Wilmington, NC
R02919-005-003-000 Gallo Virginia M $592,541 $592,541
120 Hallbrook Farms Circle, Wilmington, NC
R02919-007 -002-000 Spann Richard E Janet M $448,601 $448,601
1102 Congressional Lane, Wilmington, NC
R02920-003-004-000 Curtis A Lawrence Geraldine E $511,925 $511,925
8709 Lake Nona Lane, Wilmington, NC
R02920-003-006-000 Smith David W Karen R $632,258 $632,258
8710 Lake Nona Lane, Wilmington, NC
R02920-003-0 14-000 Zamparelle Frederick L Laurie $216,760 $216,760
8902 Mahogany Run, Wilmington, NC
R02920-003-020-000 Dimartino Michael Rose B $853,107 $853,107
8905 Saint Ives Place, Wilmington, NC
R02920-003-021-000 Banta Susan Kay $587,059 $587,059
8903 Saint Ives Place, Wilmington, NC
R02920-003-022-000 Munoz C Frank Lourdes T Etal $861,519 $861,519
8901 Saint Ives Place, Wilmington, NC
R03017-001-001-000 Jefferies John R $784,579 $784,579
1701 Futch Creek Rd, Wilmington, NC
R03611-006-004-000 Hajzak Peter Rosemary $19,000 $19,000
138 Beawood Rd, Wilmington, NC
R03611-006-005-000 Hajzak Peter Rosemary $149,664 $149,664
142 Beawood Rd, Wilmington, NC
R03700-002-059-000 Recht G Thomas Katharine J $549,742 $549,742
8802 Old Overton Way, Wilmington, NC
R03700-002-183-000 Taylor Richard Sandra $199,999 $199,999
8500 Galloway National Drive, Wilmington, NC
g~:t1
-..,
NEW HANOVER COUNTY BOARD OF BOOK 1
I EQUALIZATION AND REVIEW, AUGUST 14,2007 PAGE 386
Assessed Affirmed
Parcel ID Owner Value Value
R03 707-001-001-000 Costello Timothy D Kimberly A $751,556 $751,556
8703 Thornblade Circle, Wilmington, NC
R03707-002-007-000 Rhoads Howard H Joyce Y $609,315 $609,315
8648 Fazio Drive, Wilmington, NC
R03 707-002-009-000 Fitzgerald Arthur G Nancy L $618,551 $618,551
400 Wild Dunes Circle, Wilmington, NC
R03 707-002-010-000 Burton Harold M Julie A $495,216 $495,216
402 Wild Dunes Circle, Wilmington, NC
R03 707 -004-024-000 Mellen Lawrence E Roberta W $462,933 $462,933
620 Wild Dunes Circle, Wilmington, NC
R03708-002-011-000 Taylor Richard Sandra $144,880 $144,880
8702 Thornblade Circle, Wilmington, NC
R03712-001-017-000 Dunn Nancy W $978,357 $978,357
8312 Bald Eagle Lane, Wilmington, NC
R03712-002-008-000 Beagle Wayne Kimberly $180,000 $180,000
8337 Bald Eagle Lane, Wilmington, NC
R03 712-002-0 13-000 Beagle Wayne Etal $250,000 $250,000
8409 Bald Eagle Lane, Wilmington, NC
R03 712-002-0 18-000 Brinson Jacob $365,284 $365,284
8429 Bald Eagle Lane, Wilmington, NC
R03 712-002-0 19-000 Blalock Charles M $372,113 $372,113
I 8433 Bald Eagle Lane, Wilmington, NC
R03 720-00 1-006-000 Foster Robert D Jr Karen K $1,265,343 $1,265,343
8024 Bald Eagle Lane, Wilmington, NC
R04207 -009-009-003 Mitchell Jewell M $32,860 $32,860
1525 Marne Drive, Wilmington, NC
R04814-0 12-009-000 Monroe Dorothy Mae $65,032 $65,032
1003 Rankin Street, Wilmington, NC
R04816-0 17 -002-000 Weisman Richard A $257,900 $257,900
114 Barnard Drive, Wilmington, NC
R0551 0-009-0 15-000 Wynne Frances H $173,844 $173,844
4114 Hoggard Drive, Wilmington, NC
R06600-003-0 1 0-000 Smith Letha Mae Life Estate $126,766 $126,766
525 Ponderosa Lane, Wilmington, NC
R07616-003-002-001 Russ Denver C $125,373 $125,373
5503 Myrtle Grove Rd, Wilmington, NC
R09217 -023-013-000 Smith H Winfield Jr $407,062 $407,062
434 S Fourth Ave, Wilmington, NC
ADJOURNMENT
There being no further business, Chairman Caster recessed the 2007 Board of Equalization and
Review at 3:00 p.m. The meeting will reconvene on August 24, 2007 at 9:00 a.m.
Respectfully submitted,
J~P~
I Teresa P. Elmore
Deputy Clerk to the Board
8Sv
~