E&R 2008-02-20
-.,
I
NEW HANOVER COUNTY BOARD OF
EQUALIZATION AND REVIEW, FEBRUARY 20,2008
ASSEMBLY
The New Hanover County Board of Equalization and Review met on Wednesday, February 20,2008,
at 9:00 a.m. in Conference Room 601 of the New Hanover County Government Center, 230 Government
Center Drive, Wilmington, North Carolina. The purpose of the meeting was to hear appeals flIed by property
owners regarding their tax value assessments.
BOOK 1
PAGE 464
Members present were: Chairman William A. Caster, Commissioner William A. Kopp, Jr. and
Commissioner Nancy H. Pritchett.
Vice-Chairman Robert G. Greer and Commissioner Ted Davis, Jr. were absent.
Staff members present were: Assistant Tax Administrator Roger Kelley, Appraiser Pete Richardson,
Appraisal Supervisor Henry J. Montgomery, and Deputy Clerk to the Board Kymberleigh G. Crowell.
Board of Equalization and Review Chairman Caster called the meeting to order.
Appellants were informed that the Board would hear the appeals and make decisions following the
hearings and that the Assistant Tax Administrator would notify each appellant by mail of the Board's decision.
TAX APPEAL PRESENTATIONS
The Board heard appeal presentations from the following individuals regarding the 2007 tax
assessment of real property:
I 1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
Charles G. and Sheron G. Buis, property owners of 121 Spring Creek Ln., Wilmington, NC R037l8-
007-013-000.
Jacques Allen, property owner of207 Vistamar Dr., Wilmington, NC; R04414-001-038-000.
Lisa S. Lefler, property owner of 324 Pierpoint Dr., Wilmington, NC; R04417 -008-003-000.
Edward R. Bartow, property owner of 6209 W olfhead Ct., Wilmington, NC; R04418-003-029-000.
Grace Hannafey, representing the P J Hannafey Life Est., property owner of 124 Waynick Blv.,
Wrightsville Beach, NC; R06308-021-006-000.
David Ray, property owner of 5420 Myrtle Grove Rd., Wilmington, NC; R07612-005-001-000.
James Sharrard, representing Richard J. and Jean E. Liccione, property owners of 619 S. Lumina
Ave., Wrightsville Beach, NC; R06315-004-028-000.
Break: Chairman Caster called a break from 12:25 p.m. until 1:09 p.m.
I
8. Blany Page, property owner of7806 Marymount Dr., Wilmington, NC; R03600-008-046-000.
9. Neil Adams and Stephen Marks, representing Neil Adams ET AL, property owner of2605 N. Lumina
Ave., Wrightsville Beach, NC; R05218-001-026-000.
10. Carolyn E. Ripley, property owner, and husband Charles Ripley, of20 Oceanic Ave., Wrightsville
Beach, NC; R06308-016-013-000.
1 1 (a). Steven Harris, property ownerof722 S. Lumina Ave., WrightsvilleBeach, NC; R06319-006-007-
001.
II(b). David Manning, representing Mark S. Manning ETAL, property owner of 722 S. Lumina Ave.,
Wrightsville Beach, NC; R06319-006-007-002.
12. Rachel B. Johnson, property owner, and friend Eloise V. Howard, of 400 Virginia Ave., Carolina
Beach, NC; R08807-003-002-012.
In deliberations after the hearing of the appeals, the Board affirmed the assessed values as follows:
9f:g
~
NEW HANOVER COUNTY BOARD OF
EQUALIZATION AND REVIEW, FEBRUARY 20, 2008
Parcel ID
Owner
Assessed
Value
BOOK 1
PAGE 465
Affirmed
Value
R02918-002-012-000 KINNA MARY LOU $435,971 $435,971
8806 SAWMILL CREEK LN
WILMINGTON NC
R02919-002-014-000 HOLLINGSWORTH GLENN W JUDY A $560,163 $560,163
908 SAL TWOOD LN
WILMINGTON, NC
R02919-003-031-000 THURSTON ROBERT A ETAL $552,855 $517,402
8712 BARDMOOR CIR
WILMINGTON, NC
R03718-007-013-000 BUlS CHARLES G SHERON G $380,348 $365,348 (reduced land
121 SPRING CREEK LN value by $15,000)*
WILMINGTON, NC
*The Board directed staff to also reduce land values of lots R03718-007-009-000,
R03718-007-010-000, R03718-007-011-000, and R03718-007-012-000 by $15,000.
R037 I 8-007-035-000 KING EDSEL 0 BARBARA A $355,594 $355,594
130 SPRING CREEK LN
WILMINGTON, NC
R04413-007-014-000 CROOM MARTIN H JANET C $288,377 $288,377
7200 LOUNSBERRY CT
WILMINGTON, NC
R04414-001-023-000 HALL VIVIAN HANCOCK $268,201 $268,201
211 VISTAMAR DR
WILMINGTON, NC
R04414-001-038-000 ALLEN JACQUES MARGARET $300,337 $300,337
207 VISTAMAR DR
WILMINGTON, NC
R04417-008-003-000 LEFLER LISA SKINNER $399,784 $378,773 (reduced
324 PIERPOINT DR building value by
WILMINGTON, NC $21,011 and changed
Quality Grade to C+)
$532,711 (reduced pool
value by $10,082)
R04418-003-029-000 BARTOW EDWARD R COLLEEN P $542,793
6209 WOLFHEAD CT
WILMINGTON, NC
R04509-002-0 I 7 -000 VOGLER RONALD W $187,255
113 TREASURE ISLAND WAY
WILMINGTON, NC
R045 I 3-009-0 11-000 BASCOME WARREN H $242,079
4104 WAYLONRD
WILMINGTON, NC
R05218-002-019-000 MILES DAVID R SHELLEY A $3,289,519
2622 N LUMINA AVE
WRIGHTSVILLE BEACH, NC
R06308-021-006-000 HANNAFEY P J LIFE EST $1,634,214
124 WAYNICKBLV
WILMINGTON, NC
R07 612-005-001-000 RAY DAVID W JRLISAG $115,431
5420 MYRTLE GROVE RD
WILMINGTON, NC
R03600-008-046-000 PAGE BLANY $275,009
7806 MARYMOUNT DR
WILMINGTON, NC
gr:g
$187,255
$242,079
$3,143,760
$1,429,640 (reduced land
value by $17 I ,000)
$115,431
$275,009
..,
NEW HANOVER COUNTY BOARD OF BOOK 1
I EQUALIZATION AND REVIEW, FEBRUARY 20, 2008 PAGE 466
Assessed Affirmed
Parcel ID Owner Value Value
R08818-0 16-006-0 I 4 WARD ROBERT ELIZABETH MOTICKA $218,377 $217,425
302 CANAL DR
CAROLINA BEACH, NC
R03811-002-006-000 SMITH LANTY L MARGARET C $898,247 Rescheduled
3 INLET HOOK RD to March 7, 2008
WILMINGTON, NC
R044 I 8-007 -002-000 PEZZONI JOHN V $275,817 $275,817
320 VISTAMAR DR
WILMINGTON, NC
R05218-001-026-000 ADAMS NEIL ETAL $2,101,293 $2,101,293
2605 N LUMINA AVE
WRIGHTSVILLE BEACH, NC
R05705-006-00 1-034 COLONY CLUB CONDO LLC $307,791 $307,791
1714 SIGNATURE PL
WILMINGTON, NC
R05720-021-025-000 DUNBAR DANIEL B ELIZABETH $879,330 $824,323
19 W GREENSBORO ST
WRIGHTSVILLE BEACH, NC
R05813-001-007-003 HUDSON ELSIE ET AL $2,321,518 $2,194,767
1709 N LUMINA AVE
WRIGHTSVILLE BEACH, NC
I R06308-006-011-000 JOHNSON MARY P $1,500,000 $1,350,000
18 E RALEIGH ST
WRIGHTSVILLE BEACH, NC
R06308-006-0 I 3-000 JOHNSON MARY P $1,200,000 $1,200,000
14 E RALEIGH ST
WRIGHTSVILLE BEACH, NC
R06308-0 I 6-0 I 3-000 RIPLEY CAROLYN E $655,075 $655,075
20 OCEANIC AVE
WRIGHTSVILLE BEACH, NC
R06308-019-002-053 CHOTINER GERALD PEGGY A $798,413 $798,413
95 S LUMINA AVE
WRIGHTSVILLE BEACH, NC
R063 I 1-002-004-000 LINDEN II LLC ETAL $2,304,403 $2,194,033
321 S LUMINA AVE
WRIGHTSVILLE BEACH, NC
R06315-004-028-000 LICCIONE RICHARD J JEAN E $1,347,433 $1,347,433
619 S LUMINA AVE
WRIGHTSVILLE BEACH, NC
R06319-004-004-000 FUNDERBURK B H MRS HEIRS $1,738,555 $1,480,653
712 WAYNICKBLV
WRIGHTSVILLE BEACH, NC
R06319-006-007 -001 HARRIS STEVEN G CHARLOTTE C $1,092,731 $1,073,156
722 S LUMINA AVE
WRIGHTSVILLE BEACH, NC
R06319-006-007 -002 MANNING MARK SETAL $1,092,731 $1,073,156
722 S LUMINA AVE
WRIGHTSVILLE BEACH, NC
I R08807 -003-002-012 JOHNSON RACHEL B $280,677 $280,677
400 VIRGINIA AVE
CAROLINA BEACH, NC
8E9
~
NEW HANOVER COUNTY BOARD OF
EQUALIZATION AND REVIEW, FEBRUARY 20, 2008
BOOK 1
PAGE 467
Parcel ill
Owner
Assessed
Value
Affirmed
Value
R0901O-007-003-009 WARD ROBERT M BETTY MOTIKA
404 S CAROLINA BEACH AVE
CAROLINA BEACH, NC
$192,811
$190,146
TAX APPEALS WITHDRAWN
Assistant Tax Administrator Kelley reported that the following appellants have agreed to an adjusted
value and withdrawn their appeals. The Board affirmed the assessed values of the following:
Assessed Affirmed
Parcel ID Owner Value Value
R02900-003-368-000 CAGLARCAN EROL B LESLIE WIEGLE $42 I ,954 $421,954
8805 NEW FOREST DR
WILMINGTON, NC
R03706-003-006-000 GOSEWISCH ARTHUR RAE TRUST $373,252 $373,252
701 SQUIRE LN
WILMINGTON, NC
R03707-003-011-000 STONE CHARLES R JR PATRICIA H $699,042 $699,042
8729 FAZIO DRIVE
WILMINGTON, NC
R037 14-005-001-000 OYSTER POINT DEVELOPMENT CO $30,000 $30,000
1001 OYSTER POINT DR
WILMINGTON, NC
R037 14-005-002-000 OYSTER POINT DEVELOPMENT CO $30,000 $30,000
1005 OYSTER POINT DR
WILMINGTON, NC
R037 14-005-003-000 OYSTER POINT DEVELOPMENT CO $30,000 $30,000
1009 OYSTER POINT DR
WILMINGTON, NC
R03714-005-004-000 OYSTER POINT DEVELOPMENT CO $36,000 $36,000
1013 OYSTER POINT DR
WILMINGTON, NC
R03 719-002-0 I 2-000 BLUM TROY E LUCIA E $66,000 $66,000
1433 FINAL LANDING LN
WILMINGTON, NC
R03 719-004-02 7 -000 TAYLOR RICHARD SANDRA $200,000 $200,000
1429 AVENEL DR
WILMINGTON, NC
R0411O-003-001-000 POPE WADE & REGISTER RF $64,297 $64,297
316 CASTLE HAYNE RD
WILMINGTON, NC
R04417-004-013-000 NICHOLS CHARLES G SR ELIZABETH $278,046 $278,046
7110 KEY POINT DR
WILMINGTON, NC
R04417-004-035-000 EAMES PHILIP M CLAUDIA R $314,168 $314,168
405 GRAND FLORA CT
WILMINGTON, NC
R04513-003-007 -000 KINSLEY KENNETH H VALERIE D $67,200 $67,200
1822 HESS ST
WILMINGTON, NC
R05009-005-027 -000 WILSON CHRISTOPHER R STEPHANY $680,000 $680,000
111 OLD EASTWOOD RD
WILMINGTON, NC
!F9
I..... j
-.,
NEW HANOVER COUNTY BOARD OF BOOK 1
I EQUALIZATION AND REVIEW, FEBRUARY 20, 2008 PAGE 468
Assessed Affirmed
Parcel ID Owner Value Value
R05509-017-003-000 ORRELL ROBERT HENRY JR $850,453 $850,453
3220 WRIGHTSVILLE AVE
WILMINGTON, NC
R05514-00 I -031-000 SGH COASTAL PROPERTIES LLC $170,000 $170,000
930 BONHAM AVE
WILMINGTON, NC
R05709-00 1-0 I 7-000 TILLMAN JOHN R DONNA S $443,890 $443,890
1822 VINCENNES PL
WILMINGTON, NC
R057I6-010-018-000 SEAL ELSTON JR JANICE G $749,795 $749,795
27 LOOKOUT HARBOR WAY
WRIGHTSVILLE BEACH, NC
R05720-0 I 8-008-001 W WARREN LLC $300,671 $300,671
1102 N LUMINA AVE
WRIGHTSVILLE BEACH, NC
R05720-0 18-008-0 13 W WARREN LLC $301,270 $301,270
1102 N LUMINA AVE
WRIGHTSVILLE BEACH, NC
R05720-021-003-00 1 CHRISTIAN MICHAEL S PATRICIA S $974,583 $974,583
28 W HENDERSON ST
WRIGHTSVILLE BEACH, NC
I R06308-0 11-008-003 JOHNSON KATHY PAINTER $386,821 $386,821
5 W ATLANTA ST
WRIGHTSVILLE BEACH, NC
R063 I 8-005-004-000 YOUNG H CLIFTON LIFE ESTATE $842,821 $842,821
832 SCHLOSS ST
WRIGHTSVILLE BEACH, NC
R06705-006-055-000 DEBELLO THOMAS CPA TRICIA T $164,000 $164,000
196 SAINT MARK CT
WILMINGTON, NC
R08505-002-020-000 LAWS CARL E LINDA F $235,676 $235,676
710 TIARA DR
WILMINGTON, NC
R08806-004-030-008 HARRIS WILLIAM E GAIL B $327 ,549 $327,549
325 TEAKWOOD DR
CAROLINA BEACH, NC
R08807-007-012-000 MARTIN VITO CHARLOTTE A $267,120 $267,120
167 DELAWARE AVE
CAROLINA BEACH, NC
R08807-007-013-000 MARTIN VITO ANN S $169,663 $169,663
203 GEORGIA AVE
CAROLINA BEACH, NC
R088 13-003-00 1-000 RAYLE WILLIAM E JR SALLY L H $200,000 $200,000
822 KENNETH AVE
CAROLINA BEACH, NC
R08813-003-002-000 RAYLE WILLIAM E JR SALLY L H $200,000 $200,000
820 KENNETH AVE
CAROLINA BEACH, NC
I R088 18-009-001-000 POPE CATHERINE W WADE H $260,327 $260,327
321 GOLDSBORO AVE
CAROLINA BEACH, NC
0179 ~
NEW HANOVER COUNTY BOARD OF BOOK 1
EQUALIZATION AND REVIEW, FEBRUARY 20, 2008 PAGE 469
Assessed Affirmed
Parcel ID Owner Value Value
R08818-009-005-000 DAVIS JOHNIE W $412,467 $412,467
310 WILSON AVE
CAROLINA BEACH, NC
R08818-0 I 2-007 -000 ALBERS RICHARD R JANE E $186,055 $ I 86,055
407 N FOURTH ST
CAROLINA BEACH, NC
R09006-03 7 -008-000 BOOZELL JENNIFER $279,410 $279,410
3 10 FAYETTEVILLE AVE
CAROLINA BEACH, NC
R09006-040-0 I 3-000 YOUNGBLOOD JOSEPH C $207,273 $207,273
311 FAYETTEVILLE AVE
CAROLINA BEACH, NC
R0901O-011-001-020 ATKINSON SHEREE M HARRY V $414,379 $414,379
314 COLUMBIA AVE
CAROLINA BEACH, NC
R090 1 0-0 11-00 I -024 GRANT IRA N $421,654 $421,654
312 COLUMBIA AVE
CAROLINA BEACH, NC
R090 I 0-0 I 7 -001-007 REEVES REBECCA EDYTHE $196,682 $196,682
600 S CAROLINA BEACH AVE
CAROLINA BEACH, NC
R090 10-0 17 -001-010 SCHULZ GEORGE MARY JANE LIFE $196,682 $196,682
600 S CAROLINA BEACH AVE
CAROLINA BEACH, NC
R090 1 0-023-003-000 KING LINDY CURTIS $354,044 $354,044
316 SUMTER AVE
CAROLINA BEACH, NC
R09200-001-243-000 WYMAN WILLIAM P MARION C $468,348 $468,348
337 SEALANE WAY
KURE BEACH, NC
R09213-023-002-000 ZECCA F M SR REV LIV TR ET AL $ I ,600,000 $1,600,000
406 N FORT FISHER BLV
KURE BEACH, NC
ADJOURNMENT
There being no further business, Chairman Caster recessed the 2007 Board of Equalization and
Review at 3:20 p.m. The meeting will convene February 27, 2008 at 9:00 a.m.
Respectfully submitted,
~.U
K mberleigh G. Crowell
Deputy Clerk to the Board
6t:g