E&R 2008-05-08
I
I
I
-.,
NEW HANOVER COUNTY BOARD OF
EQUALIZATION AND REVIEW, MAY 8, 2008
ASSEMBLY
The 2007 New Hanover County Board of Equalization and Review met on Thursday, May 8, 2008, at
9:05 a.m. in Conference Room 601 of the New Hanover County Government Center, 230 Government Center
Drive, Wilmington, North Carolina. The purpose of the meeting was to hear appeals flIed by property owners
regarding their tax value assessments.
BOOK 1
PAGE 502
Members present were: Chairman William A. Caster (afternoon session only), Vice-Chairman Robert G.
Greer, Commissioner William A. Kopp, and Commissioner Nancy H. Pritchett (only for morning session and old
business portion of meeting).
Commissioner Ted Davis, Jr. was absent.
Staff members present were: Tax Administrator Roger Kelley, Appraisal Supervisor Henry J.
Montgomery, Appraiser Pete Richardson, and Deputy Clerk to the Board Kymberleigh G. Crowell.
Board of Equalization and Review Vice-Chairman Greer called the meeting to order.
TAX APPEAL PRESENTATIONS
The Board heard appeal presentations from the following individuals regarding the 2007 tax assessment of
real property. Each appellant was informed that the Board would make decisions following the hearings and that
the Tax Administrator would notify each appellant by mail ofthe Board's decision.
1. Pamela Watkins, property owner of 125 Rogersville Rd, Wilmington, NC; R05611-002-006-002.
2. Cynthia A. Fischer and Jack A. Hunter, property owners of 609 Airlie Rd, Wilmington, NC; R05700-006-
015-001.
3a. Wayne Branscome, representing Wayne G. Branscome ETAL, property owner of 635 Airlie Rd,
Wilmington, NC; R05713-018-001-000.
3b. Anne K. Cunningham, property owner of707 Airlie Rd, Wilmington, NC, R05713-018-006-000.
3c. Joanne G. Davenport, property owner of705 Airlie Rd, Wilmington, NC, and Jim Cushing; R05713-0 18-
007-000.
4. Debra Bakalis Rallis, Frank Pinkston and Anne Pinkston, representing Debra Bakalis Rallis ETAL,
property owner of 2512 N Lumina Avenue Ext, Wrightsville Beach, NC; R05806-001-001-032.
5. Carol J. and Richard J. Orwig, property owners of6819 Towles Road Ext, Wilmington, NC; R06313-003-
026-000.
6. Andrew H. Hall, property owner of7167 Carolina Beach Rd, Wilmington, NC; R08200-005-061-000.
7. Charles Bell, Stephanie DePue, Maurice Canady, and Perry Barwick, representing Harbor Oaks
Boataminium Inc, property owner of 1080 Saint Joseph St, Carolina Beach, NC; R08814-004-002-067.
Break: Vice-Chairman Greer called for a break at 12:30 p.m. Chairman Caster reconvened at 1 :08 p.m.
8. Richard M. and Maclyn M. Slack, property owners of703 Airlie Rd, Wilmington, NC; R05717-004-004-
000.
9. William Raney, representing Marianna Orli, property owner of 107 Florida Ave, Carolina Beach, NC;
R08807-009-005-000.
10. Pete Richardson, representing James P. and Brenda M. Pierce, property owners ofllOl S LakeParkBlv,
Carolina Beach, NC; R090 14-002-021-064.
9Lg
~
NEW HANOVER COUNTY BOARD OF
EQUALIZATION AND REVIEW, MAY 8, 2008
BOOK 1
PAGE 503
In deliberations after the hearing of the appeals, the Board affirmed the assessed values as follows:
Branscome Wayne G ET AL
635 Airlie Rd, Wilmington, NC
*For 2008, staff is to reIook at AirIie Brook Drive land values.
Cunningham Thomas F Anne K $493,824
707 Airlie Rd, Wilmington, NC
*For 2008, staff is to relook at Airlie Brook Drive land values.
Davenport Joanne G $534,567
705 AirIie Rd, Wilmington, NC
*For 2008, staff is to relook at AirIie Brook Drive land values.
Rallis Debra Bakalis ETAL $999,485
2512 N Lumina Avenue Ext, WrightsviIle Beach, NC
Parcel ill
R050 18-003-002-000
Owner
Saunders Frances K Hrs
809 Eastwood Rd, Wilmington, NC
Watkins Peter Bruce Pamela
125 RogersviIle Rd, Wilmington, NC
Hunter Jack A Cynthia A
609 AirIie Rd, Wilmington, NC
R05611-002-006-002
R05700-006-0 I 5-00 I
R057l3-0 I 8-001-000
R05713-0 18-006-000
R05713-0 I 8-007 -000
R05806-00 I -00 1-032
R063 13-003-026-000
R08200-005-061-000
R08814-004-002-067
R05700-006-009-000
R057 I 7-004-004-000
R05806-001-001-01 I
R05806-00 1-00 I -025
R05806-001-001-059
R08807 -009-005-000
R090 14-002-021-064
Pierce James P Brenda A
1101 S Lake Park Blv, Carolina Beach, NC
Assessed
Value
$381,115
$110,599
$180,000
$442,440
Affirmed
Value
$316,315
$110,599
$140,000
(Reduced land value by
$40,000 due to elevation)
$442,440*
$493,824*
$534,567*
$938,265
(Reduced building value
by $61,220 due to second
floor building valuation
inconsistency)
$1,068,476 $1,048,364*
$959,020
$180,000
$180,000
$424,123
$1,106,364*
$916,738
$180,000
$180,000*
$1,010,439
$961,366
$1,009,322
$122,000
(Reduced land value by a
total of -90% due to being
unbuildable)
$380,923
Commissioner Nancy Pritchett rejoined the meeting at 2:35 p.m. Commissioner William A. Kopp left
the meeting at 2:40 p.m.
Orwig Richard J Carol J
6819 Towles Road Ext, Wilmington, NC
*For 2008, staff is to reIook at land values in entire area.
Hall Andrew H Sandra L $1,138,768
7167 Carolina Beach Rd, Wilmington, NC
*For 2008, staff is to relook at area for equity.
Harbor Oaks Boataminium Inc
1080 Saint Joseph St, Carolina Beach, NC
Marshburn Harry Hrs
511 Airlie Rd, Wilmington, NC
Slack Richard M Maclyn M
703 Airlie Rd, Wilmington, NC
*For 2008, staff is to relook at this parcel in addition to AirIie Brook Drive land
values.
Clark Kevin 0 Cheryl L T $1,010,439
2504 N Lumina Avenue Ext, WrightsviIle Beach, NC
CoastIand Corporation $972,7 I 6
2506 N Lumina Avenue Ext, WrightsviIle Beach, NC
Hansen Michael G ETAL $1,009,322
2508 N Lumina Avenue Ext, WrightsviIle Beach, NC
Orli Marianna $488,000
107 Florida Ave, Carolina Beach, NC
9L9'
-.,
I
NEW HANOVER COUNTY BOARD OF
EQUALIZATION AND REVIEW, MAY 8, 2008
BOOK 1
PAGE 504
TAX APPEALS WITHDRAWN
Tax Administrator Kelley reported that the following appellants have agreed to an adjusted value and
withdrawn their appeals. The Board affirmed the assessed values of the following:
Assessed Affirmed
Parcel ID Owner Value Value
R02920-003-0 12-000 Schramm Larry J Cheryll L $462,895 $462,895
8903 Mahogany Run, Wilmington, NC
R03017-001-011-000 Ballard Dorothy H $733,370 $733,370
1805 Futch Creek Rd, Wilmington, NC
R04114-001-002-000 Morehead Marketplace L TD PTNRP $199,000 $199,000
1618 Castle Hayne Rd, Wilmington, NC
R04400-003-005-000 Wood William E $572,431 $572,431
7336 Darden Rd, Wilmington, NC
R04400-003-009-000 Wood William Eldridge $672,649 $672,649
7342 Darden Rd, Wilmington, NC
R04517-003-001-001 Johnson Joseph H Jr Ann $3 17,544 $3 17,544
1910 Sneeden Rd, Wilmington, NC
R05700-006-018-001 Bowers Daryl M $405,001 $405,001
617 Airlie Rd, Wilmington, NC
R05714-008-011-000 Alford W Charles Penny M $295,394 $295,394
133 Stokley Dr, Wilmington, NC
R05720-034-0 19-000 Mclean Family Trust $1,198,409 $1,198,409
I 17 E Augusta St, Wrightsville Beach, NC
R06308-022-003-000 Greiner James C ETAL $95,000 $95,000
124 Waynick Blv, Wrightsville Beach, NC
R06308-023-008-000 Barker William G Terri J $464,310 $464,310
107 Waynick Blv, Wrightsville Beach, NC
R08814-003-0 I 7 -000 Bost Leila GST Exempt Trust $913,872 $913,872
901 Saint Joseph St, Carolina Beach, NC
R08818-002-003-000 Old North State Trust LLC ETAL $355,688 $355,688
906 N Lake Park Blv, Carolina Beach, NC
R08818-002-0 11-000 Bost Leila H Rev Trust $777,688 $777,688
809 Saint Joseph St, Carolina Beach, NC
R088 18-002-012-000 Bost Leila GST Exempt Trust $891,809 $891,809
8 I 1 Saint Joseph St, Carolina Beach, NC
R08818-002-0 13-000 Old North State Trust LLC ET AL $728,261 $728,261
900 N Lake Park Blv, Carolina Beach, NC
R090 I 4-002-021-027 Brinkley William L Amy R $434,395 $434,395
1101 S Lake Park Blv, Carolina Beach, NC
R090 14-002-02 1-037 Griggs William L Janet C $380,643 $380,643
1015 S Lake Park Blv, Carolina Beach, NC
OLD BUSINESS (TABLED FROM MEETINGS OF APRIL 22 AND 24, 2008)
Tax Administrator Kelley reported that the following properties were old business that is being
resubmitted this day for the Board consideration. In deliberations, the Board affirmed the assessed values as
follows:
Parcel ID
Owner
Assessed
Value
Affirmed
Value
I
R02900-002-040-000
Pridgen Terry L Monique D $313,542 $225,688*
633 Creekwood Rd, Wilmington, NC
* At Board's request, staff reevaluated land value for subject property and corrected
land equity for subject property.
8Lg
~
NEW HANOVER COUNTY BOARD OF
EQUALIZATION AND REVIEW, MAY 8, 2008
BOOK 1
PAGE 505
Parcel ID
Owner
Assessed
Value
Affirmed
Value
R060 13-0 16-1 0 I -000
Schneiderman Stacy L Jon ETAL $196,442 $184,636*
2338 Adams St, Wilmington, NC
*Board approved a change of value under Consent Agenda during April 220d meeting
while the recommendation cover sheet reflected a recommendation of "no change".
Property owner was sent correspondence reflecting correct new value. This action is
to correct the Board's record.
Slusser John S Shelley P $250,570 $191,083*
630 Creekwood Rd, Wilmington, NC
* At Board's request, staff reevaluated land value for subject property and corrected
land equity for subject property.
McGee Thomas James Heather A $557,084 $543,644*
626 Creekwood Rd, Wilmington, NC
* At Board's request, staff reevaluated land value for subject property and corrected
land equity for subject property.
R02900-003-00 1-003
R02900-003-002-000
ADJOURNMENT
There being no further business, Chairman Caster recessed the 2007 Board of Equalization and Review at
3:00 p.m. The meeting will convene May 16, 2008 at 9:00 a.m.
Respectfully submitted,
Ki/mi,o, 0 D; it (l. ~.M~
KyMb~r~well
Deputy Clerk to the Board
LLg