The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About05-22-2018 BOER MINUTESASSEMBLY The 2018 New Hanover County Board of Equalization and Review met on Tuesday, May 22, 2018 at 9:00 a.m. in the Lucie Harrell Conference Room of the New Hanover County Government Center, 230 Government Center Drive, Wilmington, North Carolina. The purpose of the meeting was to hear appeals by property owners regarding their 2018 tax value assessments. Members present for the session were: Chairman Hector Ingram, 1st Co-Chairman Brad White, 2nd Co-Chairman Fred Gainey, Jason Swain and Wes Turbeville. Staff members present were: Asst. Tax Administrators Lawana Schulze, Appraisal Supervisor James Paulk, Appraisers Ron McWatty, Eric Davis, Eileen Haley and, Gregory Davis, Administrative Support Secretaries Michelle Martin and Juanita Wallace. Chairman Hector Ingram called the meeting to order at 9:00 a.m. AGENDA ITEM # 1: Approval of Minutes Approval of April 17, 2018 & May 11, 2018 minutes. Brad White MOVED, SECONDED by Fred Gainey to approve minutes the motion carried 5 to 0. AGENDA ITEM # 2: Old Business None AGENDA ITEM # 3A: Tax Appeal Presentations 9:00 AM Session Tab# Parcel ID Owner Situs Address Appealed Value Recommend Value Affirmed Value 1 (R02800-001-183-000) ACPR Leasehold LLC 191 Porters Neck Rd $8,587,700 $8,587,700 $8,587,700 (Commercial Appraiser Eric Davis represented ACPR Leasehold LLC) Motion: Brad White MOVED, SECONDED by Fred Gainey to Uphold Recommended Value. Upon vote, the motion carried 5 to 0. Tab# Parcel ID Owner Situs Address Appealed Value Recommend Value Affirmed Value 3 (R04919-004-026-000) GS II University Centre LLC 354 S College Rd $9,977,600 $9,977,600 $9,977,600 (Commercial Appraiser Eric Davis represented GS II University Centre LLC) Motion: Brad White MOVED, SECONDED by Fred Gainey to Uphold Recommended Value. Upon vote, the motion carried 5 to 0. Tab# Parcel ID Owner Situs Address Appealed Value Recommend Value Affirmed Value 11 (R07100-003-038-000) Lowes Home Centers Inc. 5110 S College Rd $9,588,300 $9,588,300 $9,588,300 (Commercial Appraiser Eric Davis represented Lowes Home Centers Inc.) Motion: Brad White MOVED, SECONDED by Fred Gainey to Uphold Recommended Value. Upon vote, the motion carried 5 to 0. Tab# Parcel ID Owner Situs Address Appealed Value Recommend Value Affirmed Value 9 (R06200-007-003-001) Fleming Catherine L 0 Head Rd $1,428,600 $1,386,000 $1,050,000 Motion: Brad White MOVED, SECONDED by Jason Swain to Reduce Value to $1,050,000. Upon vote, the motion carried 5 to 0. AGENDA ITEM # 3B: Fail to show for 9 AM Session Tab# Parcel ID Owner Situs Address Appealed Value Recommend Value Affirmed Value 10 (R06309-004-012-000) Lisk Adam 6263 Ingleside Dr $2,179,900 $1,795,900 $1,795,900 Motion: Fred Gainey MOVED, SECONDED by Brad White to Uphold Recommended value. Upon vote, the motion carried 4 to 0 with Wes Turbeville being excused. AGENDA ITEM # 3C: Late Consent for 9AM Session Tab# Parcel ID Owner Situs Address Appealed Value Recommend Value Affirmed Value 4 (R05112-006-010-000) Litwak Anthony 920 Arboretum Dr $225,500 $202,900 $202,900 Motion: Jason Swain MOVED, SECONDED by Brad White to Uphold Recommended value. Upon vote, the motion carried 5 to 0. AGENDA ITEM # 3D: Rescheduled to 6/19/18 Tab# Parcel ID Owner Situs Address Appealed Value Recommend Value Appellant Opinion of Value 2 R03700-003-146-000 Forest Creek Plantation Inc 1000 Porters Neck Rd $1,213,100 $839,500 $500,000 5 R05718-008-004-000 Jimmy Warren LLC 1308 Airlie Rd $11,500 $11,500 N/A 7 R05718-009-018-000 Jimmy Warren LLC 1306 Airlie Rd $4,000 $4,000 N/A 8 R05718-009-020-000 Jimmy Warren LLC 1308 Airlie Rd $1,306,500 $932,600 N/A 6 R05718-008-008-000 Jimmy Warren LLC 1308 Airlie Rd $3,032,300 $1,734,000 N/A Motion: Fred Gainey MOVED, SECONDED by Jason Swain to Accept being rescheduled to 6/19/18 meeting. Upon vote, the motion carried 5 to 0. AGENDA ITEM # 3E: Rescind 3/13/18 Decision Value change to New Recommended Value Tab# Parcel ID Owner Situs Address Appealed Value Recommend Value Appellant Opinion of Value 74 R08818-006-016-000 Island Marina Ent LLC 702 Saint Joseph St $1,217,900 $436,500 $200,000 75 R08818-006-051-000 Island Marina Ent LLC 620 Saint Joseph St $742,800 $372,500 $370,000 Motion: Brad White MOVED, SECONDED by Fred Gainey to rescind 3/13/18 decision value and, accept new recommended value. Upon vote, the motion carried 5 to 0. AGENDA ITEM # 4: Affirmation of Signed and Agreed to Value/Data Corrections per Appraisers Assistant Tax Administrator Lawana Schultz presented the signed and agreed list to the board for approval. TAB # NBHD PARID OWN1 SITUS NOTICE VALUE RECOMMEND VALUE 1 G2R10 R01700-001-006-000 SZCZERBIAK STEPHEN J JR 104 MCDOUGALD DR $653,600 $623,100 2 F9K01 R02920-001-010-000 MCNALLY RONALD E REV TRUST ETAL 1225 FUTCH CREEK RD $621,800 $560,700 3 G5C45 R03300-001-066-000 THORNTON WILL P PAMELA O 853 HORNE PLACE DR $56,200 $28,100 4 F9K10 R03620-004-039-000 COSTA MARIO W 526 SCENIC CIR $812,000 $621,800 5 F9S01 R03805-003-001-000 MILLER DIANE JON K 8609 BALD EAGLE LN $264,300 $193,000 TAB # NBHD PARID OWN1 SITUS NOTICE VALUE RECOMMEND VALUE 6 G5C60 R04100-001-110-000 HANOVER LAKES LLC 2311 LAKESIDE CIR $45,200 $2,300 7 E4K15 R04419-001-068-000 LRR NO 2 PROPERTIES LLC 3109 RIVENDELL PL $731,500 $517,800 8 H2D15 R04913-016-006-000 JONES GARY R 102 MONTGOMERY AVE $65,900 $65,900 9 H2D15 R04913-018-069-000 PAULINE PLACE OWNERS 3049 PAULINE LN $31,300 $9,400 10 CFCM2C R05006-001-016-035 DABNEY RUSTY E 311 JUDGES RD $119,400 $56,000 11 E5G73 R05111-001-004-000 ROBINS ANDREW J REBECCA N 827 FOX RIDGE LN $541,300 $526,800 12 E5G75 R05114-009-080-000 LE COLLIN M LANH T 1801 S MOORINGS DR $799,800 $642,700 13 H5D15 R05407-035-018-000 RUSSELL R D BETTY REV LIV TR 2024 DELGADO AVE $232,000 $182,600 14 H5D15 R05407-036-002-000 RTW REAL ESTATE INVESTMENTS LLC DEXTER ST $276,400 $212,300 15 H5B25 R05509-001-003-000 DALTON THOMAS M KIMBERLY A 812 FOREST HILLS DR $746,900 $699,900 16 E8B01 R05600-003-006-001 CARTER TONY E VICKIE E 1637 AIRLIE FOREST CT $492,400 $371,000 17 E8B01 R05600-003-025-000 MURPHY TAMARA RICHARD III 1637 AIRLIE FOREST CT $134,100 $33,400 18 D1C25 R05600-007-006-000 WEST PRONG 2 LLC 6037 WRIGHTSVILLE AVE $170,700 $0 HOA 19 E5G01 R05705-002-040-000 KOZEN RAYMOND E REV TRUST 1828 STARFIX TER $976,300 $833,600 20 E5G97 R05710-006-053-000 MAZER LINDA L NORMAN B 1602 DYE PL $598,600 $517,300 21 D1C50 R06108-002-010-000 TC IVEY PROPERTIES LLC 5031 PEACHTREE AVE $307,400 $206,300 22 D1C50 R06108-002-011-000 TC IVEY PROPERTIES LLC 5033 PEACHTREE AVE $275,600 $206,300 23 D1C50 R06108-002-013-000 TC IVEY PROPERTIES LLC 5032 PARK AVE $307,400 $238,300 24 D1C50 R06108-002-014-000 TC IVEY PROPERTIES LLC 5030 PARK AVE $258,800 $196,000 25 D1C50 R06108-002-015-000 TC IVEY PROPERTIES LLC 5026 PARK AVE $275,200 $206,300 26 D1C50 R06108-002-020-000 TC IVEY PROPERTIES LLC 5028 PARK AVE $275,400 $206,300 27 D5C00 R06208-013-004-000 GALES EDWIN F MELINDA S 6801 GREENVILLE LOOP RD $174,000 $160,600 28 D1C46 R06208-013-098-000 SUMMERWALK DEVELOPMENT LLC CANE ISLAND PL $4,400 $0 HOA 29 D1C46 R06208-013-099-000 SUMMERWALK DEVELOPMENT LLC TAMARISK LN $2,000 $0 HOA 30 D1C46 R06208-013-100-000 SUMMERWALK DEVELOPMENT LLC TAMARISK LN $1,800 $0 HOA 31 E9O20C R06308-013-009-003 REEVES WILLIS H JR HELEN N 16 E COLUMBIA ST $956,300 $935,500 32 D5S10 R06309-002-027-000 FISSCHER ROLF H 126 MARTINGALE LN $885,200 $785,400 TAB # NBHD PARID OWN1 SITUS NOTICE VALUE RECOMMEND VALUE 33 B2C12 R06600-005-027-000 INGWERSEN GRETCHEN 728 ANTLER DR $304,700 $332,600 34 D4C15 R06607-005-018-000 JONES CYNTHIA HILL 922 HOOD DR $188,300 $168,300 35 I6G01 R06609-004-010-000 MULLINS KATHLEEN 909 ROBERT E LEE DR $260,900 $240,100 36 B2C41 R07112-012-011-000 PARK BRUCE C KATHLEEN R 5233 SHADOW BRANCH LN $294,600 $288,800 37 B3S45 R07600-003-108-000 MILLER JON KIMBERLY DIANE ROSE 5507 WATCH TOWER ROW $409,000 $391,800 38 B4B10 R07600-006-420-000 MCGANN GERALD T JR 330 MOTTS FOREST RD $324,600 $298,500 39 B6S01 R07620-002-003-000 SASKO RICHARD A JOANNA M 5518 PEDEN POINT RD $780,700 $636,100 40 B6S10 R07908-003-017-000 BROOKS PHILIP W STEPHANIE B 1521 MARSH COVE LN $486,100 $220,400 41 A3S74 R08200-005-278-000 MUSSELWHITE NEILL H III SALIENT PT $257,400 $179,400 42 A6S00 R08519-002-007-000 SCHWENKER CLIFFORD G 416 OCEANA WAY $1,606,100 $1,039,000 43 A6S10 R08811-003-010-000 BLUEDUNES LLC 1207 CANAL DR $363,600 $84,600 44 A6O13 R08811-009-001-000 CAMPBELL THOMAS R TAMARA M 1118 CANAL DR $173,100 $173,600 45 A5O16 R09014-015-009-000 YOUNG HENRY H III DOROTHY 1311 SNAPPER LN $270,900 $270,900 46 A5O26 R09017-004-009-000 BAHHOUTH VICTOR JOCELYNE 502 SOUTH CAROLINA AVE $323,100 $302,700 47 D5S10 R06300-001-022-000 BULLARD JAMES SUSAN 113 WINDLASS DR $2,067,800 $1,455,000 48 D8S01 R07200-004-002-002 TIBBETTS ROBERT COLLEEN 7859 MASONBORO SOUND RD $587,100 $516,900 49 D8K45 R07200-005-007-003 DECHESERE JAY HEATHER 240 CABBAGE INLET LN $362,600 $326,700 50 E9S01 R05716-005-002-000 ESINHART JAMES SUSAN 11 BERMUDA DR $1,906,200 $1,786,300 51 A3S52 R08200-005-267-000 LAUREL COMPANIES 7712 DUNEWALK CT $123,500 $272,000 52 G8C01 R03300-001-012-000 NIX INVESTMENTS 2405 CASTLE HAYNE RD $226,400 $58,900 53 A6O00 R08815-003-002-000 MOORE TODD CHRISTINE 1018 N CAROLINA AVE $857,000 $906,900 54 B4G10 R07800-006-434-000 MUNGO HOMES 6109 SEAGROVE CT $308,300 $308,300 55 B4G10 R07800-006-399-000 MUNGO HOMES 425 ISLANDS END CT $83,300 $83,300 56 B4G10 R07800-006-402-000 MUNGO HOMES 413ISLANDS END CT $83,300 $83,300 57 B4G10 R07800-006-403-000 MUNGO HOMES 409 ISLANDS END CT $83,300 $83,300 58 B4G10 R07800-006-410-000 MUNGO HOMES 424 ISLANDS END CT $83,300 $83,300 59 B4G10 R07800-006-416-000 MUNGO HOMES 448 ISLANDS END CT $87,600 $87,600 60 B4G10 R07800-006-409-000 MUNGO HOMES 420 ISLANDS END CT $83,300 $83,300 TAB # NBHD PARID OWN1 SITUS NOTICE VALUE RECOMMEND VALUE 61 B4G10 R07800-006-411-000 MUNGO HOMES 428 ISLANDS END CT $83,300 $83,300 62 B4G10 R07800-006-413-000 MUNGO HOMES 436 ISLANDS END CT $87,600 $87,600 63 C1BS0 R06109-004-032-000 THE OLEANDER CO INC 1741 TIBURON DR $1,700 $377,900 64 C1BS0 R06109-004-036-000 THE OLEANDER CO INC TIBURON DR $200 $54,100 65 E5G55 R05111-005-003-000 UEBELE STEVEN A ERIN A 708 PLANTERS ROW $921,300 $1,329,200 66 CGC00 R04914-002-025-001 BLANTON RL & CO 25 N KERR AVE $1,253,100 $930,000 67 CAOB7C R08814-001-001-002 ALLEN EDWIN S JR LINDA 1003 BENNTE LN UNIT A $112,500 $94,800 68 CGCC0 R01100-010-005-000 HENDERSON DANNY SARA 5115 N COLLEGE RD $289,000 $240,000 69 CAO06 R08819-006-003-000 FERRER MARK 312 N CAROLINA BEACH AVE $1,012,000 $788,000 70 CGC01 R01720-001-002-000 WENMAN LLC 326 HERMITAGE RD $295,000 $240,000 71 B5D01 R07619-002-016-008 POPE DONALD DEBBIE 5913 WISHING WELL LN $13,600 $27,200 *72 CHC00 R04817-021-008-000 GRIMES DIANE 617 PRINCESS ST $82,200 $39,400 *73 CHC00 R04817-021-010-000 GRIMES DIANE 107 N 7TH ST $63,400 $63,400 Motion: Fred Gainey MOVED, SECONDED by Jason Swain to Accept Recommended Values for Tab #’s 1-73. Upon vote, the motion carried 5 to 0. AGENDA ITEM # 5: New Business Chairman Hector Ingram asked if, there was any new business. The next meeting is on Tuesday, June 19, 2018 with Chairman Hector Ingram, Brad White, Fred Gainey, Jason Swain and Wes Turbeville expected to attend. Upcoming meetings Tuesday, July 10 and July 24, 2018. AGENDA ITEM # 6: Recess There being no further business to consider, Chairman Hector Ingram asked for a motion to recess. 1st Co-Chairman Brad White moved; seconded by 2nd Co-Chairman Fred Gainey to recess Board of Equalization and Review at 10:15 am. The motion carried 5 to 0. Respectfully submitted, Michelle Martin and, Juanita Wallace