HomeMy WebLinkAbout08-08-2017 BOER MINUTESASSEMBLY
The 2017 New Hanover County Board of Equalization and Review met on Tuesday, August 8, 2017 at 9:00 a.m. in the Lucie Harrell Conference Room of the New Hanover County Government Center,
230 Government Center Drive, Wilmington, North Carolina. The purpose of the meeting was to hear appeals by property owners regarding their 2017 tax value assessments.
Members present for the session were: Paul Magnabosco (Chairman), Nancy Pritchett, Brad White, James Stokley and Fred Gainey.
Staff members present were: Asst. Tax Administrator Lawana Schulze, Appraisal Supervisor James Paulk, Appraisers Steve Walker, Larry Moeller, Ron McWatty, Randy Kahl, Gregory Davis,
Administrative Support Secretaries Michelle Martin & Juanita Wallace.
Chairman Paul Magnabosco called the meeting to order at 9:00 a.m.
AGENDA ITEM # 1: Approval of Minutes
Approval of July 25, 2017 minutes. Brad White MOVED, SECONDED by Fred Gainey to approve minutes the motion carried 5 to 0.
AGENDA ITEM # 2: Old Business
Chairman Paul Magnabosco informed Board Members that tabled appeal # R08500-002-041-013, 701 Inlet Acres, Mr. William A. Brown will be heard on Tuesday, August 22, 2017 at 1pm.
AGENDA ITEM # 3A: Tax Appeal Presentations 9:00 AM Session
The Board heard appeal presentations from the following individuals regarding the 2017 tax assessment of real property. Each appellant was informed that the Board would make decisions
following the hearings and they would be notified by mail of the Board’s decision.
Tab# Parcel ID Owner Situs Address Appealed Value Recommend Value
Affirmed Value
4 (R02500-002-003-000) Johnson, R Charles Barbara L 312 Hermitage Rd. Castle Hayne $801,800 $504,400
$504,400
Motion: Brad White MOVED, SECONDED by James Stokley to Accept Recommended Value of $504,400. Upon vote, the motion carried 5 to 0.
AGENDA ITEM # 3B: Affirmation of Recommended Values for Scheduled Hearings for Appellants Who failed to Appear @ 9:00 AM Session
Tab# Parcel ID Owner Situs Address Appealed Value Recommend Value
Affirmed Value
6 (R04400-003-016-000) Gonzalez Luis F Ana Elisa Azuara 719 Middle Sound Loop Rd. $268,900 $263,100 $263,100
Tab# Parcel ID Owner Situs Address Appealed Value Recommend Value
Affirmed Value
8 (R04417-007-023-000) Campbell Jeanne S 315 Smugglers Ct. $151,000 $160,400 $160,400
Tab# Parcel ID Owner Situs Address Appealed Value Recommend Value
Affirmed Value
9 (R04417-007-039-000) Campbell Jeanne S 313 Halyard Ct. $160,400 $160,400
$160,400
Tab# Parcel ID Owner Situs Address Appealed Value Recommend Value
Affirmed Value
10 (R04816-010-029-000) Medina Jose B Jr ETAL 317 N 26th St.. $132,700 $163,200
$163,200
Tab# Parcel ID Owner Situs Address Appealed Value Recommend Value
Affirmed Value
11 (R05605-007-109-000) CDP Holdings LLC 5006 Carlton Dr. $144,500 $144,500
$144,500
Motion: Nancy Pritchett MOVED, SECONDED by Fred Gainey to Accept Recommended Values for Tab #’s 6,8,9,10 & 11. Upon vote, the motion carried 5 to 0.
AGENDA ITEM # 3C: Withdrawn for 9:00 AM Session
Tab# Parcel ID Owner Situs Address Appealed Value Recommend Value
Affirmed Value
1 (R02000-001-037-000) Lanwillo Development Co. 413 Island Creek Dr. $43,400 $21,700
$21,700
Tab# Parcel ID Owner Situs Address Appealed Value Recommend Value
Affirmed Value
2 (R02000-001-038-000) Lanwillo Development Co. 419 Island Creek Dr. $43,400 $21,700
$21,700
Tab# Parcel ID Owner Situs Address Appealed Value Recommend Value
Affirmed Value
3 (R02000-001-039-000) Lanwillo Development Co. 425 Island Creek Dr. $42,400 $21,200
$21,200
Tab# Parcel ID Owner Situs Address Appealed Value Recommend Value
Affirmed Value
5 (R03515-001-024-000) Salazar Valentin 1006 Sheffield Dr. $264,500 $264,500
$264,500
Tab# Parcel ID Owner Situs Address Appealed Value Recommend Value
Affirmed Value
7 (R04417-004-030-000) Cherry Sandra Ray F. 402 Spike Rush Ct. $268,300 $236,000
$236,000
Motion: Fred Gainey MOVED, SECONDED by Brad White to Accept Recommended Values for Tab #’s 1,2,3,5 & 7. Upon vote, the motion carried 5 to 0.
AGENDA ITEM # 4A: Tax Appeal Presentations 1:00 PM Session
No appellants present for 1:00 PM Session
AGENDA ITEM # 4B: Affirmation of Recommended Values for Scheduled Hearings for Appellants Who failed to Appear @ 1:00 PM Session
Tab# Parcel ID Owner Situs Address Appealed Value Recommend Value
Affirmed Value
17 (R04518-002-011-000) Watters Thomas S 1955 Middle Sound Loop Rd. $1,134,700 $1,134,700 $1,134,700
Tab# Parcel ID Owner Situs Address Appealed Value Recommend Value
Affirmed Value
18 (R04518-002-014-000) Watters Thomas S 1955 Middle Sound Loop Rd. $164,100 $90,300 $90,300
Tab# Parcel ID Owner Situs Address Appealed Value Recommend Value
Affirmed Value
19 (R05600-005-061-000) Collins David B Jr Jana H 200 Cavalier Dr. $407,700 $404,000 $404,000
Tab# Parcel ID Owner Situs Address Appealed Value Recommend Value
Affirmed Value
20 (R05600-005-066-000) Yates Brenda L Rev Trust 1309 Kingfisher Ct. $393,900 $419,100 $419,100
Tab# Parcel ID Owner Situs Address Appealed Value Recommend Value
Affirmed Value
24 (R06618-005-008-002) Taylor Stephen G Savanna S 217 Satara Dr. $338,900 $338,900 $338,900
Motion: Nancy Pritchett MOVED, SECONDED by Jay Stokley to Accept Recommended Values for Tab #’s 17,18,19,20 & 24. Upon vote, the motion carried 5 to 0.
AGENDA ITEM # 4C: WITHDRAWN FOR @ 1:00 PM Session
Tab# Parcel ID Owner Situs Address Appealed Value Recommend Value
Affirmed Value
22 (R06008-008-001-000) Wortman James Kris 2516 Canterbury Rd. $469,200 $474,200 $474,200
Tab# Parcel ID Owner Situs Address Appealed Value Recommend Value
Affirmed Value
23 (R06008-009-015-000) Barmore James A Jr Kathryn C 1939 Knollwood Dr. $498,700 $498,700 $498,700
Motion: Fred Gainey MOVED, SECONDED by Jay Stokley to Accept Recommended Values for Tab #’s 22 & 23. Upon vote, the motion carried 5 to 0.
AGENDA ITEM # 5: Affirmation of Signed and Agreed to Value/Data Corrections per Appraisers
Assistant Tax Administrator Lawana Schultz presented the signed and agreed list to the board for approval.
Tab Nbhd Parcel ID Owner Situs Address Appealed
Value Affirmed Value
1
G2R15
R01100-006-007-001
KELLY ELMER C
471 BLOSSOM FERRY RD
$111,000
$54,000
2
CGCC1
R02600-004-008-000
NORTH CHASE ASSOCIATES LLC
3224 N COLLEGE RD
$4,104,900
$3,575,000
3
G6C05
R02610-002-005-000
RUBRIGHT MARY BETH JEFFERY
3901 BRINKMAN DR
$195,100
$178,300
4
F5D01
R02800-001-037-000
GAVALINA ENTERPRISE LLC
7561 PLANTATION RD
$73,900
$38,100
5
F9G07
R02919-003-011-000
GLASS JIMMY L PEGGY J
1118 TENNWOOD DR
$470,200
$423,200
6
F8C29
R03500-005-290-000
RAHGO MICHAEL ETAL
2401 WHITE RD
$165,400
$162,500
7
F9B10
R03600-005-059-000
BATCHELOR RHONDA K REV LIV TR
7947 SANDERLING PL
$465,600
$441,800
8
F9B10
R03600-005-065-000
BRINKLEY WILLIAM LEWIS AMY
7936 SANDERLING PL
$415,200
$361,400
9
F8B25
R03616-004-022-000
EUBANKS JAMES R BEATRICE A
703 TRACE DR
$244,800
$229,600
10
F8C20
R03618-011-007-000
BLIZZARD VERNON
7524 ELKMONT CT
$188,800
$181,600
11
F8B25
R03619-003-016-000
REVILLA LUIS A LESLIE D HERNANDEZ
422 UPLAND DR
$226,600
$192,700
12
F8B20
R03619-016-017-000
IVENTOSCH SANDI KIRK
7625 MALLOW RD
$328,500
$314,300
13
CGCX2
R04200-001-025-O00
WILMINGTON NC VA 2011 LLC
1705 GARDNER DR
$20,440,200
$20,440,200
14
F7C04
R04306-009-005-000
THOMAS SHAMIKA L KENNETH E
4913 GORDON RD
$120,400
$109,500
15
F8C30
R04312-001-010-000
AGHJAYAN SHAWNDRIA AVERY
7014 DAYBREAK LN
$152,200
$139,200
16
F8C31
R04314-009-037-000
WORRELL STEPHEN C
6607 WOOD SORRELL RD
$151,700
$144,000
17
E4B30
R04400-004-022-000
GORSETT FAMILY LIVING TRUST
1002 APPALOOSA TRL
$558,500
$523,400
18
CHBX0C
R04720-008-004-001
LANASA JUSTIN W
116 N FRONT ST
$351,300
$315,000
19
H4D15
R04818-044-013-000
WHITE ISABELLE B ETAL
1607 ORANGE ST
$106,200
$106,200
20
H4D25
R05409-010-003-000
PORT CITY COURIER LLC
611 S 7TH ST
$53,500
$38,900
21
H4D25
R05409-010-034-000
PORT CITY COURIER LLC
710 CRONELY ALY
$9,800
$4,900
22
H4D25
R05409-010-035-000
PORT CITY COURIER LLC
714 CRONELY ALY
$9,800
$4,900
23
H4D25
R05410-025-005-000
NEFF CONSTANCE D
809 S 13TH ST
$115,000
$97,400
24
I2G03
R05416-012-021-000
ALLEGOOD CARLTON W
1538 MAGNOLIA PL
$388,200
$359,500
25
I2B04
R05420-008-004-000
PURDOM LISA G
1800 S LIVE OAK PKY
$497,200
$445,200
26
D1C50
R06107-007-015-000
GOUDARZI G GEORGE
4907 OLEANDER DR
$384,800
$384,800
27
I4C01
R06509-003-002-000
OATES HUGH F SR
2886 WORTH DR
$73,500
$68,800
28
B2C55
R07100-004-046-000
TURANO BARRY J MARY ANN LIFE EST
4901 MERLOT CT
$204,800
$204,800
29
B9C01
R07900-005-015-000
SEARLS PATRICIA T JAY L
6809 MYRTLE GROVE RD
$249,500
$251,500
30
B5C10
R07907-009-002-000
ANDERSON DANIEL KATHLEEN
6248 SENTRY OAKS DR
$302,400
$328,000
31
A2G60
R08410-001-044-000
DELEEUW FRANS A HELENE
220 CLUB CT
$236,200
$236,200
32
A2G60
R08506-002-011-000
HINES CLINTON L KAREN L
8119 MAINSAIL LN
$355,900
$353,400
33
A6O00
R08807-013-001-000
BROWN JUNE WWATKINS REV TRUST
1818 CANAL DR
$656,600
$527,700
Motion: Brad White MOVED, SECONDED by Fred Gainey to Accept Affirmed Values for Tabs 1-33. Upon vote, the motion carried 5 to 0.
AGENDA ITEM # 6: New Business
Chairman Paul Magnabosco asked if, there was any new business. Secretary Juanita Wallace informed the Board that appeal R05000-003-180-000 6232 Chalfont Dr., owners Evans, Walter Richard
Sue Ann were rescheduled to October 3, 2017 meeting but, was left on July 11th agenda which was affirmed @ $623,200. Brad White moved; seconded by Nancy Pritchett to rescind affirmed
value of $623,200. Upon vote motion carried 5 to 0.
AGENDA ITEM # 7: Upcoming Meetings
Chairman Paul Magnabosco discussed upcoming meeting which is scheduled for Tuesday, August 22, 2017 @ 9 am-4pm with Chairman Paul Magnabosco, Nancy Pritchett, Jason Swain, Brad White
and James Stokley to hear cases. Future meeting scheduled Tuesday, September 5, 2017 from 9am-5pm with Chairman Paul Magnabosco, Co-Chairman Hector Ingram, Nancy Pritchett, Jason
Swain & Brad White.
AGENDA ITEM # 8: Recess
There being no further business to consider, Chairman Paul Magnabosco asked for a motion to recess. Nancy Pritchett moved; seconded by Fred Gainey to recess Board of Equalization
and Review at 1:35 pm motion carried 5 to 0.
Respectfully submitted,
Michelle Martin & Juanita Wallace