The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About12-05-2017 BOER MINUTESASSEMBLY The 2017 New Hanover County Board of Equalization and Review met on Tuesday, December 5, 2017 at 9:00 a.m. in the Lucie Harrell Conference Room of the New Hanover County Government Center, 230 Government Center Drive, Wilmington, North Carolina. The purpose of the meeting was to hear appeals by property owners regarding their 2017 tax value assessments. Members present for the session were: Chairman Paul Magnabosco, Nancy Pritchett, Brad White and, Fred Gainey. Staff members present were: Asst. Tax Administrators Lawana Schulze & Scott Saunders, Appraisers Steve Walker, Heather Haas and Chris Horn, Administrative Support Secretaries Michelle Martin and Juanita Wallace. Chairman Paul Magnabosco called the meeting to order at 9:00 a.m. AGENDA ITEM # 1: Approval of Minutes Approval of November 28, 2017 minutes. Brad White MOVED, SECONDED by Nancy Pritchett to approve minutes the motion carried 4 to 0. AGENDA ITEM # 2: Old Business None AGENDA ITEM # 2B: Take agenda items out of order Chairman Paul Magnabosco asked for motion to take agenda items out of due to weather to allow appellants time to arrive. Fred Gainey Moved; Seconded by Nancy Pritchett to take agenda out of order. Upon vote, the motion carried 4 to 0. AGENDA ITEM # 3A: Tax Appeal Presentations 9:00 AM Session None showed AGENDA ITEM # 3B: Failure to appear for 9 AM Session Tab# Parcel ID Owner Situs Address Appealed Value Recommend Value Affirmed Value 3 (R02500-002-009-004) Kuffel Leo F 125 Gladiolus Rd. $79,400 $67,400 $67,400 Tab# Parcel ID Owner Situs Address Appealed Value Recommend Value Affirmed Value 4 (R04212-007-007-000) Shappell Elaine V 4505 Noland Dr. $144,100 $153,500 $153,500 Tab# Parcel ID Owner Situs Address Appealed Value Recommend Value Affirmed Value 5 (R05515-002-003-005) Saviano Lisa 4510 Fountain Dr. $154,800 $154,800 $154,800 Tab# Parcel ID Owner Situs Address Appealed Value Recommend Value Affirmed Value 6 (R07914-003-004-000) Smith Paul Dale Georgia C 2541 Yolanda Ln. $46,200 $46,200 $46,200 Tab# Parcel ID Owner Situs Address Appealed Value Recommend Value Affirmed Value 8 (R09200-001-002-023) Snellman Erick A Mary Jo Pcola 312 Kure Dunes Ln $178,100 $146,000 $146,000 Tab# Parcel ID Owner Situs Address Appealed Value Recommend Value Affirmed Value 9 (R09200-001-024-000) Martinez Paul Connie 520 Fifth Ave. $301,900 $301,900 $301,900 Tab# Parcel ID Owner Situs Address Appealed Value Recommend Value Affirmed Value 12 (R09213-005-015-000) Peterson Helen K Life Estate 213 Atlantic Ave $520,100 $520,100 $520,100 Motion: Nancy Pritchett MOVED, SECONDED by Brad White to Accept Recommended Values for Tab #’s 3,4,5,6,8,9 &12. Upon vote, the motion carried 4 to 0. AGENDA ITEM # 3C: Withdrawn for 9 AM Session Tab# Parcel ID Owner Situs Address Appealed Value Recommend Value Affirmed Value 1 (R01700-003-001-000) Radewicz Karen Dee 3629 Sondey Rd. $55,200 $43,700 $43,700 Tab# Parcel ID Owner Situs Address Appealed Value Recommend Value Affirmed Value 2 (R01810-003-010-000) Glenn Ronnie Letcie L 111 Millhouse Rd. $117,600 $133,200 $133,200 Tab# Parcel ID Owner Situs Address Appealed Value Recommend Value Affirmed Value 10 (R09205-012-019-000) Bisher William M Martha E ETAL 115 Ocean View Ave. $165,700 $165,700 $165,700 Tab# Parcel ID Owner Situs Address Appealed Value Recommend Value Affirmed Value 11 (R09205-012-021-000) Bisher William M Martha E ETAL 119 Ocean View Ave. $107,600 $107,600 $107,600 Tab# Parcel ID Owner Situs Address Appealed Value Recommend Value Affirmed Value 7 (R09018-006-011-000) Williams Pamela S 1420 S Lake Park Blv $381,300 $315,000 $315,000 Motion: Brad White MOVED, SECONDED by Fred Gainey to Accept Recommended Values for Tab #’s 1, 2, 10, 11 & 7. Upon vote, the motion carried 4 to 0. AGENDA ITEM # 3D: Reschedule for future date Brad White Moved; Seconded by Nancy Pritchett to reschedule R05620-001-025-000 Larson Family Trust to upcoming January 2018. Upon vote, the motion carried 4 to 0. AGENDA ITEM # 3E: Rescind Value Fred Gainey Moved; Seconded by Nancy Pritchett to rescind value from 11/28/2017 Board Meeting on R04917-004-005-000 Outdoor Creations Landscape recommended value of $212,900 due to additional information provided and case will be on upcoming meeting. Upon vote, the motion carried 4 to 0. AGENDA ITEM # 4: Affirmation of Signed and Agreed to Value/Data Corrections per Appraisers Assistant Tax Administrator Lawana Schultz presented the signed and agreed list to the board for approval. TAB # NBHD PARID OWN1 SITUS NOTICE VALUE RECOMMEND VALUE 1 D8K55 R06700-002-081-000 EFIRD HAZEL CLAIRE 5426 EFIRD RD $718,300 $478,500 2 G5C10 R02500-002-019-000 DAVIS ELEANOR 3110 CASTLE HAYNE RD $347,300 $175,900 3 CGCC1 R02620-003-008-000 T GILBERT PROPERTIES LLC 2709 SE NORTHCHASE PKY $381,000 $300,000 4 CGCX1 R03400-001-041-000 RRT & JWT III LIVING TRUST KITTY HAWK RD $214,400 $125,000 5 CGCX1 R03400-001-078-000 JFSF LLC 2902 ORVILLE WRIGHT WAY $331,900 $283,000 6 CGCC1 R03412-003-004-000 MACRIS SPIRO J 2520 N COLLEGE RD $1,124,900 $765,000 7 CGRN1 R04000-001-010-000 RADCLIFF MARK A 1855 N 421 HWY $593,900 $55,700 8 CGRN1 R04000-001-013-000 RADCLIFF MARK A 1917 N 421 HWY $158,000 $158,000 9 CGC02 R04100-002-008-000 SOUTHEASTERN FREIGHT LINE 2800 N 23RD ST $913,900 $655,500 10 G9D01 R04207-009-009-004 BULLOCK FRANCES LEE BLAINE 1521 MARNE DR $199,200 $143,600 11 CGR00C R04805-021-001-001 W G M INC 501 CORNELIUS HARNETT DR $75,700 $54,000 12 CHCM4C R04820-006-003-001 MARKET STREET CENTRAL LLC 2709 MARKET ST $180,100 $139,000 13 CHCM4C R04820-006-003-002 MARKET STREET CENTRAL LLC 2709 MARKET ST $92,100 $73,600 14 CHCM4C R04820-006-003-003 MARKET STREET CENTRAL LLC 2709 MARKET ST $145,000 $117,000 15 CHCM4C R04820-006-003-005 MARKET STREET CENTRAL LLC 2709 MARKET ST $180,100 $139,000 16 CHCM4C R04820-006-003-006 MARKET STREET CENTRAL LLC 2709 MARKET ST $101,800 $79,000 17 CHCM4C R04820-006-003-007 MARKET STREET CENTRAL LLC 2709 MARKET ST $121,500 $94,000 18 CHCM4C R04820-006-003-008 MARKET STREET CENTRAL LLC 2709 MARKET ST $109,600 $85,500 19 CHCM4 R04820-006-003-009 MARKET STREET CENTRAL LLC 2615 MARKET ST $68,200 $65,000 20 E5G60 R05107-011-016-000 ZWARG MARY A REV TRUST 2103 AINSDALE CT $525,600 $525,600 TAB # NBHD PARID OWN1 SITUS NOTICE VALUE RECOMMEND VALUE 21 H4B05H R05308-013-004-000 FEENEY JOHN ROSS 422 S FRONT ST $423,200 $328,400 22 H5C35 R05408-007-009-000 LASAR ISAAC ROSLYN F 425 STRADLEIGH RD $409,400 $374,400 23 H4C25 R05409-013-008-000 SCHMID PROPERTIES LLC 413 QUEEN ST $51,100 $24,500 24 H4C25 R05409-019-016-000 SCHMID PROPERTIES LLC 710 S 5TH AVE $55,200 $28,700 25 H6D55 R05507-002-060-000 YOUNG CAROL D 403 S KERR AVE $89,500 $95,600 26 H6D30 R05507-002-088-000 SHACKELFORD LEE MAUREEN 4806 COLLEGIATE DR $341,100 $294,100 27 H6C25T R05507-002-130-000 MURPHY JAMIE 321 S KERR AVE $109,500 $109,500 28 H6D05 R05509-004-023-000 IVEY DARREN R KAREN M 3261 CAMDEN CIR $173,000 $158,800 29 CHC07C R05509-018-005-007 OMAC ALPHA INVESTMENTS 3333 WRIGHTSVILLE AVE $281,300 $230,000 30 E7C01T R05616-001-009-010 ELLIS FRANCES P 6279 WRIGHTSVILLE AVE $162,300 $162,300 31 E7C01T R05616-001-009-015 ALDRIDGE JEFF 6279 WRIGHTSVILLE AVE $160,300 $160,300 32 E8B25 R05713-001-022-000 LAEDERACH ALAIN SILVIA B RAMOS 1932 ALLENS LN $196,700 $196,700 33 E9S25 R05720-001-008-000 ROSBRUGH JEFFREY B LORI W 605 N CHANNEL DR $689,900 $563,000 34 E9S25 R05720-007-006-001 WILLIAMS ALBERT J JR ETAL 307 N CHANNEL DR $613,000 $518,900 35 E9S25 R05720-009-007-000 LW LW LLC 209 N CHANNEL DR $564,000 $488,800 36 E9O05 R05809-002-046-000 WALKER J ELWOOD 6 NORTH RIDGE RD $1,408,300 $1,308,700 37 CIC00 R06013-015-001-000 TITAN CAROLINA CONCRETE LLC 2210 MONROE ST $853,200 $730,100 38 E9O25 R06315-004-022-000 HANOVER SEASIDE CLUB 605 S LUMINA AVE $1,781,200 $1,622,000 39 E9S15 R06315-006-027-000 COLLINS SUSAN HOWELL ETAL 614 WAYNICK BLV $1,175,000 $1,470,600 40 E9S15C R06315-006-027-001 COLLINS SUSAN HOWELL ETAL 614 WAYNICK BLV $853,200 N/A 41 E9S15C R06315-006-027-002 COLLINS SUSAN HOWELL ETAL 614 WAYNICK BLV $857,600 N/A 42 E9O25 R06315-006-028-000 COLLINS ROERT G SUSAN H 614 COBURN AVE $823,900 $763,000 43 E9S20 R06318-005-010-000 PRIEST JOSEPH G 301 WATER ST $607,000 $552,600 44 E9S20 R06318-005-012-000 PRIEST JOSEPH G 305 WATER ST $610,000 $555,600 45 E9S20 R06318-005-014-000 PRIEST JOSEPH G 309 WATER ST $597,400 $543,000 46 E9S20 R06318-005-016-000 PRIEST JOSEPH G 313 WATER ST $625,600 $570,700 47 E9S15C R06319-004-005-001 BOYER J RAHN PATTY S 5 SUNSET AVE $729,200 $585,300 48 CEO00 R06319-004-009-000 BAUCOM ALVIS MCDONALD 16 NATHAN AVE $1,048,400 $650,000 TAB # NBHD PARID OWN1 SITUS NOTICE VALUE RECOMMEND VALUE 49 E9S20 R06319-005-003-000 PRIEST JOSEPH G 6 MEIER ST $668,700 $630,200 50 E9S20 R06319-005-004-000 PRIEST JOSEPH G 4 MEIER ST $605,200 $592,900 51 D4C10 R06608-009-027-000 WHITEHEAD ROSEMARIE 3440 HAMPSHIRE DR $201,500 $201,500 52 E9O25 R06806-004-004-000 MACRIS SPIRO JAMES 914 S LUMINA AVE $975,900 $857,700 53 B4C10 R07600-006-059-000 MCGIRT GAIL LEE 1131 MCGIRT PL $53,700 $45,100 54 B4C10 R07600-006-062-000 MCGIRT GAIL LEE 1101 MCGIRT PL $268,000 $227,600 55 B4C10 R07600-006-063-000 MCGIRT GAIL LEE 1123 MCGIRT PL $108,800 $90,800 56 A6S00 R08519-002-019-000 HOOD ROBIN WHITLEY II 440 OCEANA WAY $944,700 $746,700 57 A6S00 R08519-002-030-000 BRANNEN ROBERT D PAULA J 423 OCEANA WAY $537,200 $537,200 58 A6S13 R08818-006-044-000 WOMBLE MICHAEL H 100 ROUGUE COVE DR $308,800 $251,000 59 CAOB7C R09014-011-018-001 WOODWARD INVESTORS LLC 105 TENNESSEE AVE $79,300 $63,200 60 A8O40 R09200-001-002-025 MINEO DAVID F MARY A 320 KURE DUNES LN $178,100 $146,000 61 A9O06 R09200-001-206-000 EFSTATHIOU ATHAN A MARY D 192 SEAWATCH WAY $528,400 $520,200 62 A9O06 R09200-001-207-000 SLUSSER JOHN S ETAL 164 SEAWATCH WAY $583,600 $487,100 63 A9O06 R09200-001-271-000 WATKINS GARY MAXINE ANN 523 N FORT FISHER BLV $259,200 $202,200 64 A8O40 R09205-015-008-000 SKIPPER RICHARD R 737 SAILOR CT $178,100 $138,900 65 A8O40 R09205-015-057-000 DOYLE RANDALL H KATHRYN B 822 KETCH CT $342,700 $312,500 66 A8O40 R09209-003-001-000 COLLINS JON L KIMBERLY L 409 N FORT FISHER BLV $346,300 $277,100 67 A8O40 R09209-003-015-000 HYLER EDDIE F CYNTHIA 465 N FORT FISHER BLV $585,200 $585,200 68 A8O40 R09209-003-024-000 GREENE ROBERT L SR BARBARA B 456 SANDMAN DR $495,900 $477,500 69 A8O40 R09209-013-001-000 BYRD RICHARD T PATRICIA H 434 SETTLERS LN $178,100 $138,900 70 A8O42 R09405-002-023-000 MOONEY WILLIAM J BABARA A 506 S THIRD AVE $211,700 $190,500 71 A8O42 R09405-003-015-000 BADDOUR PHILIP JR MARGARET 536 S FORT FISHER BLV $383,100 $326,000 72 A8O42 R09405-008-015-000 BELANGER KERRY E PATTI P 636 S FORT FISHER BLV $315,500 $269,100 73 A8O42 R09405-008-017-000 NILSON MARSHA 628 S FORT FISHER BLV $306,500 $253,500 74 A8O42 R09405-009-016-000 NIXDORF MATTHEW ETAL 633 S FOURTH AVE $211,800 $141,200 75 A9O45 R09409-001-012-000 PETERSON JAMES RANDALL 930 S FORT FISHER BLV $482,400 $436,200 Motion: Brad White MOVED, SECONDED by Fred Gainey to Accept Recommended Values for Tab #’s 1-75 with correction to recommended value of $139,000 on tab # 15 R04820-006-003-005 Market Street Central LLC. Upon vote, the motion carried 4 to 0. AGENDA ITEM # 5: New Business Chairman Paul Magnabosco asked if, there was any new business and, there was none. AGENDA ITEM # 6: Upcoming Meetings Chairman Paul Magnabosco discussed the upcoming meeting schedule. The next Board meeting is scheduled for Tuesday, December 12, 2017 from 9am-4pm with, Chairman Paul Magnabosco, Co-Chairman Hector Ingram, Nancy Pritchett, Brad White & Jason Swain expected to attend. Future meeting scheduled Tuesday, January 9th from 9-5pm with, Chairman Paul Magnabosco, Co-Chairman Hector Ingram, Nancy Pritchett, Jason Swain & Brad White expected to attend. AGENDA ITEM # 7: Recess There being no further business to consider, Chairman Paul Magnabosco asked for a motion to recess. Brad White moved; seconded by Fred Gainey to recess Board of Equalization and Review at 9:40 am. The motion carried 4 to 0. Respectfully submitted, Michelle Martin & Juanita Wallace